Tag: 4th judicial district
-

Cog Railway assault suspect set for spring 2026 trial, seeks use of PTSD condition in defense
The Arvada man accused of punching a Broadmoor Manitou and Pikes Peak Cog Railway parking lot employee pleaded not guilty Thursday to the assault charges at a hearing in 4th Judicial Court, setting his case for an April trial. The case started Aug. 18, when Randy Blevins, 50, and his wife were walking through the…
-

Return to Nature co-owner sees federal sentencing pushed to 2026
The federal sentencing for the co-owner of the Return to Nature Funeral Home that found itself under a multi-agency investigation in October 2023 has been pushed to March, court records show. Carie Hallford was scheduled to be in a Denver court for her sentencing Wednesday after she pleaded guilty to one count of conspiracy to…
-

Fountain thief in 2024 officer-involved shooting avoids prison time
The Walgreens thief injured after being shot by Fountain police in September 2024 was sentenced to probation Monday. The case for Brenden Burningham, 32, started on Sept. 14, 2024, when Fountain police officers responded to a robbery at the Walgreens along 7910 Fountain Mesa Road. The man had threatened employees and was armed with a…
-

A decade of legal turns in Planned Parenthood shooter case ends in a final fatal twist, with no closure
On a bitterly cold Black Friday morning 10 years ago, Colorado Springs was thrust into the crosshairs of a uniquely American tragedy. It wasn’t the first mass shooting the city had experienced (and, sadly, would not be the last). Less than a month before, on Halloween, three lives had been lost during one man’s random…
-

Competency concerns arise again for arson suspect in Teller County fire
After already being deemed competent to proceed to trial once earlier, competency concerns again took the spotlight Monday for the woman allegedly behind the Highland Lakes fire that burned nearly 170 acres near Divide last year. Lowa Tillitt, 77, also referred to as Lacey Tillitt in public records, was arrested Jan. 16 for allegedly starting…
-

On the docket this week: Roommates accused of assault, King Soopers homicide suspect back in court
Last week in court, a 4th Judicial District judge ruled to sentence a man acquitted of second-degree murder to five years in prison, and another removed themselves from the Pikes Peak Avenue homicide case. Looking ahead to the upcoming week, hearings are scheduled for Lacey Tillitt, Marquise Hutt, Jerome Scott, Gerald Brooks and Dustin Boston…
-

Hearing held for Planned Parenthood shooting suspect ahead of 10-year mark
Robert Dear Jr., the alleged gunman in the 2015 Planned Parenthood shooting that left three dead and nine injured, is in the process of being committed civilly due to his mental health after being deemed incompetent despite forced medication. Similar to the past several state hearings, Thursday’s hearing provided little new information. Instead, attorneys in…
-

El Paso County man acquitted of attempted murder during trial, but gets prison time
The El Paso County man initially charged with attempted second-degree murder stemming from a Halloween 2024 assault was sentenced to prison Monday after being acquitted of the most serious offense during trial. Gary Spicer, 78, was arrested on Oct. 31, 2024, after shooting a gun during an argument in the 200 block of Cunningham Drive…
-

Judge removes himself in Colorado Springs shopping center shooting case
El Paso County Judge Dennis McGuire recused himself from a homicide case Monday, saying he previously represented the victim as an attorney. The case revolves around the May shooting death of Bryan Parada, 38, just outside a shopping center on East Pikes Peak Avenue. The case was previously being handled by Judge David Shakes. Shakes…





