Author: Michael Karlik michael.karlik@coloradopolitics.com
-

All about the ‘quandary’: Judges talk about when Colorado Supreme Court wades into federal cases
For the most part, cases that are filed in state court proceed linearly through the state trial courts, appellate court and Supreme Court. Likewise, federal cases are heard by a federal trial judge, a federal appeals court and, on rare occasions, the nation’s highest court. But sometimes, when a federal case involves a question of…
-

10th Circuit clarifies what judges should do when juries turn in conflicting verdicts
The Denver-based federal appeals court put judges and lawyers on notice Monday that if a jury produces a verdict too confusing to interpret, a judge may ask jurors to reconsider their decision. The 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals acknowledged its prior decisions did not permit judges to let juries clarify certain kinds of verdicts…
-
Federal judge green-lights some claims for trial in death of Montezuma County jail detainee
A federal judge on Friday ended some claims and permitted others to proceed to a jury trial over the 2021 death of a severely intoxicated man in the Montezuma County jail. Surviving family members of Kelroy Newman filed suit against the county, its elected sheriff, a deputy, the hospital where Newman was seen and his…
-
Judge sides with Florissant fire district in ex-chief’s First Amendment lawsuit
A federal judge ruled on Friday that the former chief of the Florissant Fire Protection District could not prevail on the claim that his 2023 firing was retaliation for his First Amendment-protected activity. Erik Holt alleged the Teller County district’s directors terminated him because he cooperated with an investigation into potential election fraud during the…
-

Federal judge dismisses lawsuit against state, Denver energy standards for large buildings
A federal judge on Friday dismissed a lawsuit seeking to overturn regulations for achieving energy reductions in large buildings, finding the plaintiffs’ allegations about their injuries were too vague to sustain their legal challenge. Industry groups representing Colorado’s apartment owners, hotel operators and real estate developers sued the state and the City and County of…
-

State Supreme Court approves disability accommodation rules, judicial discipline rule-makers get to work | COURT CRAWL
Welcome to Court Crawl, Colorado Politics’ roundup of news from the third branch of government. The state Supreme Court enacted a new set of rules for pursuing disability accommodations on the bar exam, plus the new committee charged with crafting judicial discipline rules has begun its work. New rules • The Colorado Supreme Court heard in…
-

Appeals court chastizes Denver prosecutor for inappropriate comment on defendant’s right to silence
Colorado’s second-highest court agreed on Thursday that a Denver prosecutor inappropriately commented on a defendant’s constitutional right to silence during a jury trial, but the misconduct did not warrant a new trial in light of the overwhelming evidence of guilt. Byron L. Whitehorn is serving a prison sentence of 24 years to life after jurors…
-

Colorado Supreme Court’s rules for disability accommodations on bar exam face criticism
The Colorado Supreme Court last week adopted new rules for applicants to receive disability-based accommodations when taking the standardized test to become an attorney or legal paraprofessional, but advocates for revamping the process remain concerned about the hurdles for doing so. Last year, the General Assembly enacted a law to address concerns that professional licensing examinations were failing to…
-

Federal judge declines to reconsider rejection of challenge to Colorado Springs municipal elections
A federal judge on Tuesday stood by his previous decision that a collection of civic and voting rights groups lacked the ability to challenge the timing of Colorado Springs’ municipal elections. Last summer, U.S. District Court Judge S. Kato Crews did not address whether the city’s practice of holding local elections in odd-numbered years amounted…
-

Appeals court says Xcel may be held liable for ‘felonious killing’ after Aurora home exploded
Colorado’s second-highest court ruled last week that corporations in general — and Xcel Energy specifically — may be held liable for “feloniously killing” a person, meaning the cap that exists in state law will not apply to a jury’s award. After a 2023 trial, Denver jurors awarded the children of Carol Ross $15 million in noneconomic…





