Author: Michael Karlik michael.karlik@coloradopolitics.com
-

Judge sides with Florissant fire district in ex-chief’s First Amendment lawsuit
A federal judge ruled that the former chief of the Florissant Fire Protection District could not prevail on the claim that his 2023 firing was retaliation for his First Amendment-protected activity. Erik Holt alleged the Teller County district’s directors terminated him because he cooperated with an investigation into potential election fraud during the May 2023…
-

Federal judge permits brief window of construction on Gross Reservoir in face of appeal
Three days after ordering Denver Water to permanently halt its efforts to expand a Boulder County reservoir, a federal judge on Sunday gave the utility a brief window to proceed with necessary construction as an appeal of her decision is filed. On April 3, U.S. District Court Senior Judge Christine M. Arguello found that as…
-

HOAs subject to increased liability for guests’ injuries in common areas, appeals court rules
Colorado’s second-highest court ruled for the first time on Thursday that guests of homeowners who are injured in the common areas of homeowner associations only need to satisfy a relatively low hurdle to sue the HOA. Under Colorado law, someone who is injured on another’s property will have a harder or easier time holding the…
-

Appeals court overturns Weld County drug convictions after officer gave improper testimony
Colorado’s second-highest court on Thursday overturned a man’s drug convictions and 36-year prison sentence because a law enforcement officer improperly testified the defendant had met the legal elements to be found guilty. An expert witness cannot “usurp” the jury’s role by testifying about the conclusion jurors should reach. The Court of Appeals has previously ordered…
-

Recent adopters of wild horses may still get paid, federal judge clarifies after overturning program
A federal judge clarified on Tuesday that his decision overturning a 6-year-old program to compensate those who adopt wild horses still allows people to receive their agreed-upon payments if they were already in the middle of adoption. On March 3, U.S. District Court Senior Judge William J. Martínez overturned a set of policies governing the Adoption Incentive Program,…
-

Federal judge to Elizabeth School District: Put banned books back by weekend
A federal judge on Thursday refused to put her prior ruling on hold while an appeal plays out, and instead ordered Elizabeth School District to return 19 restricted books to library shelves by Saturday. U.S. District Court Judge Charlotte N. Sweeney rejected the Elbert County district’s claims that her original order was unfair, “breathtakingly broad”…
-
Federal judge dismisses lawsuit from middle schoolers disciplined for sexual harassment
A federal judge last week dismissed claims from a pair of former eighth grade students who alleged their Elbert County charter school violated their rights by deviating from its policies and denying them due process while investigating possible sexual harassment. The boys, identified as J.S. and C.G., attended Legacy Academy in Elizabeth during the 2022-2023…
-
Federal judge allows human trafficking lawsuit to proceed against Colorado Springs hotel operator
A federal judge agreed last week that a lawsuit could proceed against the operator of a Colorado Springs hotel for allegedly violating a 20-year-old human trafficking law. The plaintiff, a woman identified as C.J., alleged she was the victim of sex trafficking at the Days Inn by Wyndham Colorado Springs/Garden of the Gods, located at 4610…
-

Federal judge lets prisoner’s claim proceed over strip search video shared with others
A federal judge agreed last week that an incarcerated man’s claims could proceed against two state corrections employees, alleging they retaliated against him for complaining about recorded strip searches and also showed the video of one search to inmates and staff. Representing himself, Ryan James Griffin filed suit based on multiple strip searches he underwent…
-

Appeals court finds Mesa County judge incorrectly analyzed evidence for second time in sex assault trial
Colorado’s second-highest court concluded last month that a Mesa County judge used the incorrect standard when deciding if a defendant should receive a new trial — even after a prior Court of Appeals decision explicitly ordered the judge to fix his earlier evidence-related mistake. A three-judge appellate panel, by 2-1, believed then-District Court Judge Richard T.…





