Author: Michael Karlik michael.karlik@coloradopolitics.com
-

Federal judge skeptical of government’s assurances that alleged ‘alien enemies’ will receive process
A federal judge on Monday signaled she is not fully prepared to take the government at its word that it would provide appropriate procedures for non-citizens to contest their removals under an 18th Century “alien enemies” law and instead said the government’s recent actions suggested due process would not actually happen. U.S. District Court Judge…
-

Colorado Supreme Court rejects attempt to blur lines in construction industry lawsuit
The Colorado Supreme Court on Monday reiterated that breach of contract lawsuits are distinct from negligence lawsuits, and an insurance company had chosen the wrong path when it attempted to recover nearly $483,000 from an allegedly negligent construction company. For decades, the court has recognized that some civil liability claims like negligence are meant to…
-

State Supreme Court holds arguments, misconduct alleged against judge | COURT CRAWL
Welcome to Court Crawl, Colorado Politics’ roundup of news from the third branch of government. The state Supreme Court heard arguments in several cases this month, plus the details of a trial judge’s alleged misconduct have been made public for the first time since his suspension last year. Oral arguments • The Supreme Court waded through…
-

10th Circuit says judge misinterpreted meaning of ‘sudden’ in Denver property damage case
The Denver-based federal appeals court ruled on Thursday that a trial judge incorrectly interpreted the meaning of “sudden” when he concluded an insurance company need not pay for damage to a home allegedly caused by prolonged construction work nearby. Experts hired by Allstate and homeowner Michael Catalano Jr. disagreed whether the damage to Catalano’s Denver…
-

Federal judge advances convicted man’s lawsuit over $3,406 still in Denver’s possession
A federal judge this month agreed an incarcerated man may proceed to sue Denver and the commander of its major crimes division for refusing to return $3,406 that authorities confiscated after his arrest 20 years ago. Jurors convicted Brian Hicks of murder in 2011. Originally, police arrested Hicks in 2005 and charged him with attempted…
-

Federal judge allows Denver sheriff employee’s discrimination claim to proceed
A federal judge agreed on Monday that a Denver sheriff’s sergeant may proceed with his claim that he was subjected to sex-based discrimination when he was passed over for promotion in favor of female employees who allegedly were less qualified. U.S. District Court Judge Nina Y. Wang observed a forthcoming U.S. Supreme Court decision may alter…
-

Appeals court, prosecution, defense all agree judge violated Routt County defendant’s right to counsel
After the government and the defense both expressed rare agreement that a judge failed to ensure a Routt County defendant validly gave up his right to counsel, Colorado’s second-highest court ordered a redo of the proceedings on Thursday. Jurors convicted Movses Mikaelyan in 2023 for the unauthorized use of a financial device. Shortly afterward, his…
-
Federal judge allows excessive force claims to proceed against Moffat County, Craig officers
A federal judge last week permitted a man’s excessive force claims to proceed against law enforcement officers from Craig and Moffat County, who allegedly rammed him with a car as he was walking away with his hands in the air. Chief U.S. Magistrate Judge Scott T. Varholak noted that plaintiff Tanner Sholes, as alleged, was…
-

Appeals court rules dead witness’s prior testimony may be used in criminal case
Colorado’s second-highest court clarified for the first time last week that a witness who testifies in a civil case, but who dies before a related criminal case goes to trial, may have their testimony used in the criminal proceedings. A three-judge Court of Appeals panel concluded that if the criminal defendant had a “full, fair,…
-

Northeast Colorado judge inappropriately aided friend in multiple cases, discipline officials say
A judge from northeastern Colorado used his position to aid a friend across multiple cases, and ordered the pretrial release of her boyfriend who was accused of felonies, disciplinary officials alleged in a filing on Tuesday. District Court Judge Justin B. Haenlein, who presides in the 13th Judicial District of Morgan, Logan, Sedgwick, Phillips, Washington, Yuma…





