Author: Michael Karlik michael.karlik@coloradopolitics.com
-

Appeals court says prosecutors may use evidence of defendant abusing witness to boost credibility
Colorado’s second-highest court ruled last week that prosecutors may introduce evidence at trial of a defendant’s past abuse of a witness if it will help jurors understand why the witness may have originally lied to protect the defendant. Romando Marquis Jones and Dacey Spinuzzi are both serving prison sentences for the death of 14-month-old Aiden Seeley, who was Spinuzzi’s…
-

Federal judge bars government from removing accused ‘alien enemies’ from Colorado
A federal judge on Tuesday extended her order barring the government from removing non-citizens accused of being “alien enemies” from Colorado, concluding the authority invoked by the Trump administration is likely unlawful. Two weeks ago, U.S. District Court Judge Charlotte N. Sweeney issued a temporary restraining order in a case brought by two detained Venezuelan men on…
-

Federal judge sides with Colorado Symphony in violinist’s religious discrimination lawsuit
A federal judge last week found the Colorado Symphony Association had not discriminated against a violinist on the basis of her religion by placing her on leave when she did not receive a COVID-19 vaccination. Larisa Fesmire has been a violinist with the Colorado Symphony Orchestra since 1998. She described herself as a “Bible based…
-

Federal judge declines to ask 10th Circuit to review pronoun policy, tells lawyers they are free to deviate
A federal judge rejected for the second time last week a complaint from a pair of lawyers about his courtroom policy on the use of pronouns, reiterating that the attorneys are — and have been — free to refer to transgender people as they wish. “They’ve done so from the start. They’ve done so without sanction or…
-

Colorado justices to examine what happens when governments withhold key info from injured plaintiffs
The Colorado Supreme Court announced on Monday that it will decide whether injured plaintiffs do not have to strictly comply with the legal deadline for notifying the government if a public entity’s conduct makes it impossible to timely identify who should be sued. At least three of the court’s seven members must agree to hear a case…
-

Federal judge IDs flaw with Tina Peters’ request for release
A federal judge on Monday warned former Mesa County clerk Tina Peters that her request to be released while she appeals her 2024 criminal convictions appears to be brought improperly and may be subject to dismissal. Jurors convicted Peters for her role in a security breach of her office’s voting equipment. She is currently serving a…
-

Controversial cases stay on track, judge resigns following discipline probe | COURT CRAWL
Welcome to Court Crawl, Colorado Politics’ roundup of news from the third branch of government. The Denver-based federal appeals court declined to disrupt the trial court orders in a pair of controversial cases, plus a state judge resigned his seat after admitting to misconduct. 10th Circuit action • It was a good week for U.S. District…
-

Colorado justices, 5-2, rule jury may consider victim’s suicidality in fentanyl distribution case
The Colorado Supreme Court ruled on Monday that a 2022 state law allows jurors to hear about a victim’s suicidal intentions when determining if a defendant is guilty of selling fentanyl and causing the victim’s death. The justices interpreted for the first time a relatively new law imposing harsher penalties for those who distribute the synthetic opioid…
-

Federal, state judges give the do’s and don’ts of criminal appeals | APPELLATE UPDATE
Members of the state and federal appeals courts based in Denver spoke to attorneys on Friday about strategies for properly litigating criminal appeals, including how to make arguments based on body-worn camera footage. Justice Brian D. Boatright, Judge Karl L. Schock of the Court of Appeals and Judge Gregory A. Phillips of the U.S. Court…
-

Supreme Court justice, appeals judge spar over authority to decide issues | APPELLATE UPDATE
One of Colorado’s Supreme Court justices and a member of the Court of Appeals debated on Friday about how far appellate judges should go when deciding cases using reasons that are different from the ones the litigants argued in court. Justice Richard L. Gabriel described the “party presentation principle” as stemming from the idea that…





