Author: Michael Karlik michael.karlik@coloradopolitics.com
-

‘Dabs made me do it?’ Colorado justices ponder when defendants can rely on laced drugs as defense
Members of the Colorado Supreme Court struggled last week to determine where to draw the line between allowing defendants to argue they unwittingly consumed a substance that caused them to engage in criminal behavior, while also preventing a wave of unsubstantiated claims about laced drugs. Under state law, “involuntary intoxication” is an affirmative defense, meaning…
-
10th Circuit rules ex-Denver police chief entitled to immunity for 2020 protest injury
Denver’s former police chief cannot be held liable for a woman’s injury during a 2020 protest because his directives for officers to use force were “in the abstract and from a distance,” the Colorado-based federal appeals court ruled last week. The lawsuit from Suzy Dennis was one of several filed in federal court following the…
-

Colorado Supreme Court skeptical of broad municipal power to permit violations of state noise limits
Members of the Colorado Supreme Court attempted on Thursday to decipher a 38-year-old amendment to the state’s noise pollution law to determine if local governments may permit any for-profit entity to host events on private property that exceed the statewide decibel limits. In doing so, multiple justices were openly skeptical of the city of Salida’s…
-

Colorado justices ponder whether defendants must repay money police use for drug buys
If undercover police officers buy drugs from a suspected drug dealer, but they let him leave with the money and never recover it, is the defendant obligated to repay the amount as crime victim restitution? Members of the Colorado Supreme Court grappled with the question on Thursday, with multiple justices wondering how the state’s restitution…
-

Colorado justices talk about their jobs, obligation to be non-political in El Paso County school visit
The Colorado Supreme Court traveled to El Paso County on Thursday, where members fielded questions from high school students on topics that included how they got their seats, what they do to relax, and the best and worst parts of the job. “I honestly think the worst part of our job is we deal with…
-

Colorado Supreme Court rules police-guided text messages from victim’s father did not coerce defendant
The Colorado Supreme Court ruled on Monday that a text message exchange between the father of an alleged child sex assault victim and the defendant was not coercive, even though a sheriff’s investigator was guiding the accusatory texts. Patrick Nkongolo stands accused of five counts of sexual assault on a child. His alleged victim told…
-

Colorado Supreme Court wary of releasing Aurora council recording despite improper closed-door discussion
Some members of the Colorado Supreme Court appeared hesitant on Wednesday to release a recording of an Aurora City Council closed-door session, even though the state’s second-highest court found — and the city admitted — its notice to the public failed to comply with the open meetings law. Although prior Court of Appeals decisions have ruled that…
-

Colorado justices confirm SCOTUS stalking ruling limited to speech
The Colorado Supreme Court confirmed on Monday that a 2023 ruling from the nation’s highest court imposing a higher burden on stalking prosecutions does not apply to cases where the alleged stalker’s conduct, not the words he uses, is the problem. The U.S. Supreme Court handed down its ruling in Counterman v. Colorado two years ago, in…
-

Colorado justices uphold confidentiality of truck driver’s medical records after fatal crash
The Colorado Supreme Court ruled on Monday that the surviving family members of a deceased motorist may obtain the other driver’s narrative of what happened, but they cannot do it through the medical records generated from his post-accident hospital visit. Relatives of Timothy Trenshaw sought to use five sentences from the notes of an emergency…
-

Colorado Supreme Court reinstates Larimer County DA’s office on case after judge ordered new prosecutors
The Colorado Supreme Court reinstated the Eighth Judicial District Attorney’s Office on a stalking case on Monday, finding a trial judge disqualified the office based on an incorrect perception of a conflict. In an unusual unsigned opinion, the Supreme Court noted state law allows judges to remove district attorney offices from criminal cases under “special…





