Author: Michael Karlik michael.karlik@coloradopolitics.com
-

Federal judge sends claims of 13 plaintiffs to trial over police response to 2020 demonstrations
A federal judge last week agreed 13 people injured in the police response to 2020 demonstrations in Denver will have their claims of constitutional violations decided by jury trial. Numerous judges in the past five years have found Denver or its officers may be held liable for excessive force or First Amendment violations in a…
-

Appeals court finds Denver judge wrongly let child witness testify by CCTV
Colorado’s second-highest court ruled on Thursday that a Denver judge violated the constitutional rights of a juvenile defendant by allowing the victim, who was also a child, to testify in a different room out of concern for the “influence” of the defendant’s parents. However, a three-judge panel for the Court of Appeals concluded the error…
-

Federal judge dismisses $50 million defamation lawsuit from woman called ‘prostitute’ at party
A federal judge last week dismissed a woman’s defamation lawsuit that sought $50 million in damages after a party guest allegedly called her a “prostitute” to others in attendance. “No one likes being called names. But not every alleged insult gives rise to a lawsuit in federal court,” wrote U.S. District Court Judge Charlotte N.…
-

Colorado Supreme Court bars man from further legal filings due to ‘ongoing abuse’
The Colorado Supreme Court barred a Parker man on Friday from making any more legal filings by himself, finding he repeatedly pursued groundless litigation aimed at harassing his opponents. The unsigned May 23 order explained the Supreme Court had the duty to balance every person’s constitutional right to access the courts with the need to…
-

Durango & Silverton loses bid to avoid La Plata County’s land regulation at train station
The Colorado Public Utilities Commission correctly determined La Plata County had the power to regulate the improvements to a tourist train station, the state Supreme Court ruled on Tuesday in rejecting the arguments of the Durango & Silverton Narrow Gauge Railroad Company. The issues brought to the Supreme Court largely stemmed from whether the county correctly…
-

Divided Colorado Supreme Court upholds police’s pat-down of man in ‘wrong place at the wrong time’
The Colorado Supreme Court decided on Tuesday that police had not unlawfully seized a man when they patted him down in a chance encounter after he suddenly appeared outside the motel room where they were preparing to make an arrest. By 5-2, the justices believed Oscar Jonas Ganaway consented to the pat-down search, which resulted in…
-

Despite tough talk, Colorado justices punch holes in 2021 crime victim restitution ruling
In a package of five opinions released on Tuesday, the Colorado Supreme Court stood by its general interpretation of the state’s crime victim restitution law from four years ago, while it simultaneously agreed that some judges’ violations of the law are not subject to challenge. The marathon set of oral arguments last fall made clear…
-

Colorado justices reject unusual appeal by analogy in community corrections sentencing case
The Colorado Supreme Court concluded on Tuesday that state law did not entitle a man to receive credit for the time he spent in non-residential community corrections, notwithstanding the court’s own 34-year-old analogy suggesting a deduction was possible. When Ryan Wallace Bonde was terminated from a non-residential community corrections program and resentenced to prison, his…
-

Despite 2020 change, Colorado justices rule positive drug test alone can lead to child neglect finding
A divided Colorado Supreme Court ruled on Tuesday that a newborn’s positive drug test by itself can lead to a finding of child neglect, even though legislators amended the law five years ago to eliminate that trigger. The legal debate centered on the wording lawmakers chose to replace the previous understanding that a child is neglected when…
-

Colorado Supreme Court’s oral arguments, federal judge on Western Slope talks about job | COURT CRAWL
Welcome to Court Crawl, Colorado Politics’ roundup of news from the third branch of government. The state Supreme Court held arguments in several cases earlier this month, plus Colorado’s first federal district judge to sit outside of Denver spoke about his first few years in the job and the logistics associated with it. Oral arguments…





