Author: Michael Karlik michael.karlik@coloradopolitics.com
-
Appeals court clarifies defendant need not prove relationship with own children to modify restraining order
Colorado’s second-highest court clarified on July 3 that a defendant did not need to demonstrate the nature of his relationship with his biological children in order to argue that a no-contact directive infringed on his constitutional rights. Last year, the Colorado Supreme Court issued a decision in Salah v. People, addressing what should happen when…
-

Appeals court reverses Weld County robbery convictions due to unreliable witness ID
Colorado’s second-highest court reversed a defendant’s convictions out of Weld County last week, concluding the victim’s identification was unreliable and may have been the product of police influence. In August 2019, a teenage pizza delivery driver was leaving his job. Just after he closed the door to his vehicle, a man opened it, told the…
-

Appeals court orders new murder trial for teen after judge blocked self-defense evidence
Colorado’s second-highest court overturned a defendant’s murder conviction last week after concluding an Arapahoe County judge wrongly barred evidence suggesting the man acted in self-defense. There was no dispute that 18-year-old Joseph Dean McCaughin shot and killed 16-year-old Ryan Robertson in Aurora in May 2019. In the prosecution’s telling, McCaughin was jealous of Robertson, who…
-

Lakewood must release police body cam footage of teen’s fatal shooting, appeals court rules
Colorado’s second-highest court ruled last week that Lakewood is obligated to release body-worn camera footage of police fatally shooting a 17-year-old girl, notwithstanding her surviving family’s objections. A three-judge Court of Appeals panel interpreted a key transparency requirement in Colorado’s landmark police accountability law from 2020. Judge Timothy J. Schutz wrote that legislators crafted “a…
-

Colorado Supreme Court term in review: Restitution, racial bias, rescinded opinion and more
The Colorado Supreme Court’s most visible decision of its recently concluded term may actually be the one it made five years ago. In 2020, with the retirement of then-Chief Justice Nathan B. Coats, the court’s other members decided to switch to a rotational method of filling the seat, with the judicial branch’s top job term-limited…
-

Federal judge begrudgingly dismisses Club Q survivors’ claims against El Paso County, ex-sheriff
A federal judge vented his frustration with El Paso County leaders on Monday, criticizing their lackluster approach to a key gun safety law while acknowledging he was obligated to dismiss the claims against them brought by survivors of an LGBTQ nightclub shooting. “Plaintiffs can take some slim solace in the fact that, while the individual county…
-

10th Circuit rules child welfare worker immune for alleged false statements at custody hearing
The Denver-based federal appeals court ruled on Tuesday that a child welfare worker’s testimony during a temporary custody hearing, even if it was false, cannot be the basis for a civil lawsuit under the longstanding principle shielding witness statements in judicial proceedings. A trial judge previously believed the allegedly untruthful statements of former Arapahoe County…
-

10th Circuit says judge erred in denying immunity to Denver officers who arrested man for recording
The Colorado-based federal appeals court sided with two Denver police officers on Tuesday, finding they were entitled to immunity outright or to a second look at their arguments in a lawsuit over a man’s arrest for video recording at a police station. There was no dispute that a sign was posted on the window of…
-

Appeals court clarifies defendant need not prove relationship with own children to modify restraining order
The government mistakenly relied on a 2024 Colorado Supreme Court decision in arguing the nature of the parent-child relationship was relevant
-
Appeals court clarifies defendant need not prove relationship with own children to modify restraining order
Colorado’s second-highest court clarified on July 3 that a defendant did not need to demonstrate the nature of his relationship with his biological children in order to argue that a no-contact directive infringed on his constitutional rights. Last year, the Colorado Supreme Court issued a decision in Salah v. People, addressing what should happen when a convicted sex…





