Center will shift, not create spending
In early 2007, 404 University of Colorado at Colorado Springs students participated in a survey regarding plans for construction near the university. The students were asked what sort of development they would favor. Ninety-five percent believed “that a pedestrian-friendly, mixed-use development with locally owned businesses would be best,” according to the survey’s administrator, former student Jacqueline Rockwell.
The university’s administration and City Council, collaborators in the project, ignored the results. The development, brought to us by Kratt Commercial Properties, will feature big box stores including Costco, Lowes and Kohl’s, along with several smaller chain stores, such as Starbucks, Chipotle Mexican Grill, Indigo Joe’s, PetSmart and Bonefish Grill. These are hardly the “locally owned businesses” UCCS students wanted.
A recent Gazette article on the subject didn’t even acknowledge the existence of a dissenting view, saying only that “city and business leaders hope the combination of the retail center and UCCS’s facilities will encourage new employers to locate in the area, making it an economic development hub for the community” (“2 stores delayed; Costco on track,” Feb. 27) Like UCCS students, however, faculty members have expressed their concerns in no uncertain terms.
John Harner, associate professor in UCCS’s Department of Geography and Environmental Studies, described the development as “a typical suburban shopping center” and “a sterile place built to accommodate cars, not humans.”
Carole Huber, a senior instructor in the same department, pointed out that “there is nothing pedestrian-friendly, innovative or sustainable about the design.” In order to accommodate the almost doubled amount of traffic, North Nevada will expand to six lanes, creating a major barrier between the university and the cynically named “University Village.” A 40- to 80-inch retaining wall will obstruct local residents’ view of the mountains.
Kratt’s Web site mistakes the opinions of university bureaucrats for the opinion of UCCS as a whole: “The University has … had significant input into what type of development they would like to see as well as the type of businesses. They see University Shopping Center as a key part of their future growth.” With so much of the campus against them, one wonders why UCCS’s administrators are so unfailingly supportive of Kratt’s plan.
Some think that the public university has its eye on the bottom line. Huber stated, “I have no doubt that UCCS supported the project because of anticipated revenue benefits.”
The UCCS administration is also scoring political points with the economic development crowd. Mike Kazmierski, the president of the Economic Development Corporation, said, “I think this project takes our city to the next level, as far as not just trying to drag jobs in, but to grow our own jobs, and that’s an important transition for us” (“Boom or bust on North Nevada,” Oct. 29, 2006).
It’s hard to understand how Kazmierski could confuse this big-box project with home-grown jobs. The reality is that local businesses, already struggling with the economic downturn, will be unable to compete with chain-store prices. Neighboring stores will be forced to close or relocate due to increased rent. While University Village promises new jobs, many of these will simply replace those lost in established local businesses.
Nevertheless, the EDC will be sure to count the new jobs as “jobs created” without taking into account the jobs destroyed.
Springs residents will not spend more because there are new places to spend. They will simply spend in new places. Money currently flowing into local businesses will be redirected to chain stores, with out-of-state corporate headquarters claiming their share.
In fact, the city’s economy may see a reduction in overall revenue. The same amount of money will be spent, but now a portion will leave the city.
Brian Burnett, vice chancellor of administration and finance at UCCS, was speaking approvingly when he said, “If we’re successful … you won’t recognize this part of the city in 15 years.” Nobody could disagree with that statement. The only question is whether, 15 years from now, we’ll like what we’ll see.
–
Payne is a senior at UCCS and a columnist for The Scribe, UCCS’s weekly newspaper.
Cmdr. Diane Leblanc Photo by





