Midnight Rose does not fit exemption
Sometimes a cigar bar is just a cigar bar.
On Thursday, a Teller County judge ruled that The Midnight Rose Hotel and Casino in Cripple Creek doesn’t count.
The ruling will likely end smoking at the Rose, but it doesn’t clear the air over the casino smoking question.The Midnight Rose and another casino tried to use the cigar bar exemption to make an end-run around a smoking ban, in place since Jan. 1, that they say has been hurting business.
Judge Jackson Peters ruled that The Midnight Rose does not meet the requirements set by the Legislature for a cigar bar smoking exemption, and therefore, manager Donald Rosen should be fined $200 for allowing customers to smoke. The ruling followed a September trial in Cripple Creek.
The owner of The Midnight Rose could not be reached for comment; it’s unclear whether smoking will continue at the casino.
Another Cripple Creek casino is awaiting a jury trial on the same matter.
In June, Bronco Billy’s Casino declared that it met the state’s cigar bar exemption from the smoking ban and began allowing smoking in roughly a quarter of the casino floorspace. The Midnight Rose and the Double Eagle Hotel and Casino quickly followed suit.
The Double Eagle stopped allowing smoking later in the summer, but the other casinos fought the law.
In his ruling, Peters said a cigar bar is legally defined as “a place for serious smoking and drinking, where everything else is of lesser consequence. A casino is a place for gambling, first and foremost, where everything else is of lesser consequence.”
He noted that The Midnight Rose did not get five percent of its sales from alcohol, as required by the law, even when considering the value of free drinks given to gamblers.
And it did not have at least $50,000 in tobacco sales and humidor rentals.
If it continues to allow smoking, the $200 fine will quickly increase.
Bronco Billy’s, the first casino to break the smoking ban, has no plans to snuff out smokes.
“Our situation is completely different,” said the casino’s attorney, Patrick Mika. He said Bronco Billy’s allows smoking only in part of its casino, and that part is dedicated to selling alcohol and tobacco, as the law requires.
Bronco Billy’s paid to have the question decided by a jury of six people, rather than a judge, in a December trial. Until then, Bronco Billy’s will continue to let people light up.
“I’m not surprised, cause they are busier than heck,” Cripple Creek Mayor Dan Baader said.
The smoking ban cut business for casinos across the board, he said, so when a few decided to dodge the ban they gained an unfair advantage.
“The judge’s ruling sounds well-researched and reasonable, and I’m sure quite a few (other casinos, who didn’t allow smoking) are going to be glad about this ruling. I just hope we can get this mess settled,” he said.
Air Force Falcons tailback Kip McCarthy (17) in action against Navy Saturday afternoon, Sept. 29, 2007, at Navy-Marine Corps Memorial Stadium in Annapolis. Air Force lost 31-20. Photo by (THE GAZETTE/KEVIN KRECK)





