Finger pushing


Innocence undone

KETCHIKAN, Alaska — On a pale gray Sunday, the Rev. Caleb Luther stops playing the guitar and welcomes worshippers at South Tongass Alliance Church. Rain-soaked coats clutter the fold-up chairs in an elementary school gymnasium. Children squirm in their seats. Above the congregation is a basketball scoreboard and an American flag. �Today, we focus on peace,� says Luther, a young man in a plaid shirt. �What does it mean to have peace in our lives?� Standing in the third row, Cindy Starr weeps. She buries her chin into the curly black locks of her daughter, Kalie McArthur, who vacantly stares toward other churchgoers. The answer has eluded Starr and her family for more than three years, since the mentally disabled Kalie, with the petite frame of a preteen and the mind of a preschooler, was sexually assaulted at Rampart High School in Colorado Springs. The assailant was Robert Harris, a troubled 15-year-old freshman whom the school paired with Kalie in a peer training program. Her childlike mind has since descended into a dark place from which it may never emerge, experts say. Tension bubbles beneath Kalie�s twitching hands and vents itself in aggression toward strangers. It�s a world of trapped trauma where even today she asks, �Do I have to take my clothes off?� and repeats, �I�m afraid, I�m afraid, I�m afraid.� Leaving church on this Sunday, Kalie punches a woman in the buttocks when she bends to pick something up. The day before, Kalie suddenly knelt on a sidewalk and froze in place, as though she were a statue on the street, until a sibling helped her up. Peace eludes this family, which strives for normalcy through camaraderie and laughter but cannot hide the sadness and exhaustion. It was the search for it that brought the Starrs to this island fishing and tourist town in southeastern Alaska. They found a tranquil place where whales and sea lions play and bald eagles fly over a Wal-Mart. But peace? That�s not what this story is about. The boy who assaulted Kalie went to juvenile hall, was expelled from Rampart, and later from an alternative school. Now a man, he continues to get in trouble, and he is on antidepressants, his grandmother said. A Gazette examination of hundreds of pages of legal documents, expert reports and school records found that a special education department in Academy School District 20 placed one of its most vulnerable students with one of its troubled ones and later went to great lengths to avoid accepting blame for the result. The story emerged when the family asked the district to help pay for Kalie�s care after the assault and the district responded by telling them to sue. The legal battle never made it to trial, but dozens of people gave depositions and filed reports that are now public record. The district paid out the largest legal settlement in its history, and a judge found that its negligence �shocked the conscience,� yet it continues to deny responsibility. D-20 has created new standards for its peer program, but life at Rampart High School generally goes on as usual. The special education teacher responsible for pairing Harris and Kalie, Emily Sherwood, was barred from working with students in D-20, but today she works in another area district. �A safe place� Retreating to Alaska was not the family�s first attempt at a fresh start. Charley and Cindy Starr moved to the Pikes Peak region in 2003 seeking �a safe place to raise the kids.� The couple have been married for 12 years and have two children together, Michael and Lora, and Kalie from Cindy�s first marriage. Charley, who was a photo editor for the San Diego Union-Tribune, and Cindy, a speech pathologist, decided to leave San Diego for Colorado Springs after researching crime rates, weather, cost of living and schools. After a year here, it seemed their homework had paid off. He got a job shooting photos for the Air Force Academy. She found speech pathology work at Colorado Springs School District 11 and Memorial Hospital. They bought a comfortable home in northern Colorado Springs and enrolled their children in D-20, one of the best-performing school districts in the state. For Kalie, the 2003-04 school year at Rampart was one of her best, according to the family and school officials. It was such a good year, in fact, that Rampart Transition Coordinator Carol Roche suggested Kalie, then 18, stay at Rampart another year rather than transfer to a transitional program tailored for older special education students preparing for adult life. Kalie, with an IQ of 50, was not easy to care for. At age 6 she was diagnosed with pyrimidine nucleotide depletion disorder, a metabolic disorder of the brain. The diagnosis came after four years of tests and hospital stays. Only about a dozen people in the world have been diagnosed with it. Kalie takes 35 pills a day to manage the disease and its symptoms. The girl has struggled with obsessive-compulsive behaviors, repeating words and phrases, and not understanding the concept of personal space. Yet school records show she was considered manageable, and staff members characterized her as loving and interactive. �We just loved her,� Anne Beacon, a paraprofessional who worked with Kalie at Rampart, told lawyers during a court deposition after Kalie�s assault. �We would sit and rock her in the chair. She was our baby. We would fight over her … Everybody loved her.� The Starrs had settled into their new life with relative ease, but it was a different story for 14-year-old Robert Harris, who was off to a miserable start at Coronado High School, in Colorado Springs School District 11. By the school year�s end, he had racked up about 80 absences, multiple suspensions and a shoplifting arrest, according to court documents. The one thing he didn�t seem to accrue was credit: He earned a zero grade point average. Harris denies being suspended but concedes it was a difficult year for him and that he frequently skipped school. He said he left a middle school he loved, where he was on the honor roll and played football, for a place where he says he was picked on, had no friends, and didn�t want to be. �I was going through depression,� he said in a phone interview with The Gazette. The next year his family moved, and it was time for a new start at Rampart. An ill-fated match A team of 18 students worked in the field trainer program that fall, taking on special education students as their schedules allowed. Sherwood and three paraprofessionals were responsible for six special education students, and the student helpers assisted with the less severe ones. The program, 15 to 20 years old, gave help to paraprofessionals and the teacher. It gave life lessons and class credit to students. At the beginning of the 2004-05 school year, Sherwood � at the time she went by her maiden name, Szwarc � made what she later called a �sales pitch� to students during a study hall. Robert Harris appeared interested, which was all it took to get into the program. Harris never filled out an application, which Sherwood created but never used. He wasn�t screened or asked about his past. He wasn�t taught how to deal with special education students, although district materials suggest such training was available and should have been offered. And he wasn�t dismissed from the program despite repeated concerns voiced by paraprofessionals. �If you ask them (students) to do too many steps, you lose the kid, because it is too much for something they are not sure about anyway,� Sherwood said in her deposition, explaining how her attempts at an application process had fizzled. Sherwood, in an e-mail to The Gazette, said that even if Harris had undergone training, it wouldn�t have addressed sexual misconduct. Although paid staff members who work with special education students undergo such training, Sherwood said that�s impractical for teenagers. Informing teenagers that the students in their care are vulnerable might encourage them to exploit it, she said. Sherwood conceded in her deposition that Kalie was especially vulnerable to sexual abuse and should not have been paired with someone who was untrained or immature. Even so, she said she thought Harris was a good match for Kalie because he was �lazy� and his work with Kalie required minimal effort. Kalie�s work consisted of cleaning the cafeteria or using a tennis ball on a broomstick to clean scuff marks off the floor. Sherwood defended her decision to The Gazette: �The structure of the task fit his disposition,� she said in her e-mail. The paraprofessionals disagreed, and they complained about his defiance and rudeness. After about two weeks in the program, they said, Harris refused their direction. Paraprofessional Carolynn Parker stated in her deposition that she recalled asking Harris �numerous times� to �help clean up, and (Harris) just leaning back in his chair and just flat-out, to adults, saying, no, he wasn�t going to do that.� Although none of the paraprofessionals in special education Room 111 worried specifically about Robert sexually abusing Kalie, they said they questioned the pairing. They also said they warned Sherwood that the boy had taken Kalie around the school without permission. Paraprofessional Beacon testified, �After nine years of working with field trainers, you just know the good ones from the ones that shouldn�t be there. And that was � I just had this personal vibe, this feeling that he was just, you know, not right for our room.� There were other warning signs: Harris continued to rack up unexcused absences and made at least a few visits to the principal�s office, one of them for a fistfight. Harris denied being lazy and defiant with paraprofessionals or other adults. When told of their testimony about him, he said: �I know I shouldn�t even say this, but I give them the finger.� Repeated warnings Kalie�s mental disability predisposed her to be overly affectionate, with an eagerness for hugs and the trusting nature of a small child. Her Individual Education Plan, a list of goals and needs compiled by the school, stipulated that she needed help understanding �personal boundaries� and should be under adult supervision. One of her parents� key concerns, according to the IEP, was safety. One of her many needs identified was to �differentiate between people with whom she should talk to versus not talk to.� That didn�t stop staff members from allowing Harris and Kalie to work alone in the hallway and school cafeteria for up to 10 minutes without being checked on by adults. Sherwood denies ignoring Kalie�s IEP. Paraprofessionals were concerned that Harris was taking her to other parts of the school and said so to Sherwood. Beacon once retrieved Harris and Kalie from a commons area where Harris was with �four or five friends� who she said should have been in class. A week before the assault, paraprofessional Katharine Cordy � who at the time went by her maiden name, Kmiecik � told Sherwood she was concerned about Harris, according to an affidavit she later wrote instead of giving a deposition. She now lives in Killeen, Texas. �I don�t understand why RH (Robert Harris) was allowed to stay as the field trainer assigned to Kalie,� she wrote. Disrespecting staff and abandoning or endangering students were grounds for dismissal under the program�s rules, Sherwood conceded in her deposition, but she told The Gazette her verbal warnings were enough based on what she knew. Harris denied being warned by Sherwood or using his time with Kalie to hang out with friends. Sherwood said in her deposition that she believed struggling students could benefit by working with the special education population. �When they are put in a place where they are a leader and they are helping another student that doesn�t have the same abilities as they do, it empowers them.� The stairwell During seventh period on Sept. 14, 2004, Cordy noticed that Harris had taken Kalie to an area they weren�t authorized to go. When she told him to go back, he replied, �I know what I�m doing,� according to her affidavit. A few minutes later she overheard him laughing and joking with some boys about �her,� a reference to Kalie, Cordy assumed. One boy asked him: �Are you having fun?� Sherwood was running a personal errand during the first part of seventh period without signing out or finding a certified teacher to fill in for her as teachers are required to do, Rampart Principal Gil Bierman said in a deposition. She told The Gazette that her presence in the classroom would not have changed what happened. �It was simply an unfortunate coincidence that Robert assaulted Kalie during my brief absence from the school that day,� she wrote. When Sherwood returned, she ran into Beacon, who said she was going to look for Harris and Kalie. Sherwood joined her. In an incident report she wrote later, she acknowledged Harris had �neglected� Kalie previously, so when they weren�t immediately found, Sherwood �began to feel apprehensive� and summoned a search party. A schoolwide announcement on the public address system called for Robert Harris to return to Room 111. Football coach Charles Yost didn�t notice the announcement as he left Athletic Director Tom Gregory�s office before practice. He needed to stop by his classroom before heading to the fields. When he opened the doors to the stairwell, there was Kalie, pants down, moving back and forth atop Harris, whose pants were also down, except for his boxers. An investigation later determined that Kalie had not been raped. Harris pleaded guilty to unlawful sexual contact with a helpless victim. Yost said during his deposition, �And so I asked them to pull their pants up. I ran around the corner and yelled for Mr. Gregory to come out here right now. And I said we need to take these two down to the office.� Kalie seemed oblivious. She waved to other students passing through the halls and said �hi� to them. Harris apologized and pleaded with school officials, in Yost�s words, �to let him off the hook.� �He was just trying to tell me that he was sorry, and if we didn�t tell anybody, that this would � this would never happen again. That he was really sorry. And just could we look the other way. And just trying to do everything he could not to get this reported to some authority.� Harris wouldn�t be �off the hook.� And neither would Academy School District 20. CONTACT THE WRITER: 636-1098 or brian.newsome@gazette.com.

Cindy Starr, left, holds Kalie McArthur close during a church service in Ketchikan, Alaska. (KIRK SPEER, THE GAZETTE) Photo by

Kirk Speer

Tags more


Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests