Featured opinion column
Recent letters in The Gazette from Carlo Migliaccio and Lura Lee Landis Rule attempted to refute the earlier letter by Dale Comyford and made several interesting statements. The empty assertion that Comyford’s letter lacked science was followed by the remarkable contention that global warming really refers to an increase in extreme weather. Rule referred to the carbon-credit marketing film by noted eco-profiteer Al Gore as a scientific source and also recommended, of all things, a Disney flick.
If there is more extreme weather, one would have to ask to see some evidence of it. While not exactly serene, the past several years have seen rather humdrum hurricane seasons and tornado outbreaks entirely within the statistical norm, not to mention continually declining temperatures which brings a new twist to the “warming” in global warming.
According to Dr. William Gray, Emeritus Professor of Atmospheric Science at Colorado State University, and head of the Tropical Meteorology Project at CSU’s Department of Atmospheric Sciences, the increase and decrease of hurricanes is tied to oceanic circulation (http://icecap.us/images/uploads/Gray12-08.pdf) and has nothing to do with CO2 levels or so-called global warming. His forecast for 2009 is for a relatively quiet season.
Direct and indirect solar effects amplified by atmospheric and oceanic circulation are the principal drivers of climate changes and these documented cycles correlate with climate variability not only through our present interglacial period but also going back hundreds of thousands of years. Changes in CO2 follow changes in temperature, not the other way around as Gore misrepresented.
A recent paper raised the issue of increased Total Solar Irradiance during the recovery from the Little Ice Age and notes the increased solar activity which correlates with rising temperatures, “Scafetta N., R. C. Willson (2009), ACRIM-gap and TSI trend issue resolved using a surface magnetic flux TSI proxy model, Geophys. Res. Lett., 36, L05701, doi:10.1029/2008GL036307.” Some other relevant papers include “Fairbridge, R. W. and Shirley, J. H. (1987): Prolonged minima and the 179-year cycle of the solar inertial motion. Solar Physics 110, 191-220,” and “Landscheidt T. (2003): New Little Ice Age Instead of Global Warming? Energy & Environment, Volume 14, Numbers 2-3, 1 May 2003 , pp. 327-350(24).”
At the recent Heartland Conference there were five tracks of presentations and panels. One of these tracks dealt with the economic issues of climate change and one with legislative issues. Three of these tracks, comprising more than 50 sessions, dealt with various scientific aspects of climate change. The full list is available at www.heartland.org/events/NewYork09/proceedings.html.
One of the presentations is particularly relevant to the on-going debate about solar influence on terrestial climate change. Dr. David Archibald’s presentation provides an excellent overview of solar irradiance, ice core data, historical correlation with known climate shifts, past ice ages, solar cycle lengths and intensity, and most importantly, the mechanism by which solar variability impacts our climate. The relationship is “lower solar magnetic field strength means fewer sunspots, fewer sunspots means less solar wind, less solar wind means more galactic cosmic rays, more galactic cosmic rays means more low level cloud formation, more low level clouds means more sunlight reflected back into space, which in turn means less heating of the Earth’s surface and atmosphere.”
There were several presentations which refer to the potential of an extended solar minimum and long term declines through 2030. This theory was supported by Dr. Avery who linked the oceanic cycles and noted that more than 700 peer-reviewed researchers have documented the 1,500 year climate cycle.
In another presentation, Dr. Goldberg expanded on solar variability and mechanisms. Dr. Taylor discussed the impact of oceanic circulation. Dr. Easterbrook provided a chilling projection for the decades ahead at www.heartland.org/bin/media/newyork09/PowerPoint/Don_Easterbrook.ppt.
There are many hysterical claims that warming will resume by 2011 or that we have only four years left to “solve the problem of human-induced global warming. Those are predictions which we can clearly measure.
I accept the claims by the scientists whom I have referenced that cooling will continue as we enter an extended solar minimum and oceanic cool phase which will continue at least through 2030 very similar to the Sporer or Dalton Minimums.
By 2011 it will be clear which is correct.
That is, if we still have a free press.-Pico, of Colorado Springs, is a retired Navy commander, naval flight officer and economist. He is a signatory of the Manhattan Declaration.
In another twist of an ongoing saga involving the parking lot at the head of Barr Trail and the Manitou Springs Incline, it turns out that the lot is owned by Colorado Springs Utilities and not Manitou Springs. Photo by Bryan Oller, The Gazette





