It’s time to consider capping park lands
Land acquired for “open space” is supposed to stay that way forever, right? Well, not necessarily.The city of Boulder, a pioneer in the open space movement, is putting a portion of an historic old farm acquired for open space on the auction block, according to the Boulder Daily Camera. And it’s not the first time the city has returned public land to private hands, according to the story.Part of the farm has become a fiscal drain to maintain, as the story explains. Proceeds from the sale will be put to better use elsewhere in the park system. And surprisingly few protests are being registered, given that this is Boulder. This seems to me like a welcome development if it helps shatter the taboo that seems to prevail against selling open space or other parkland, even when doing so makes sense.We’ve all seen stories about Colorado Springs’ backlog in building-out parks. We periodically hear that the parks department, like every other city agency, is struggling to make ends meet. Yet the city continually acquires more acreage, almost on autopilot, through coerced land “donations” from developers and a trails and open space tax dedicated to purchasing more land.At some point, one presumes, the city will have more parks and open space in its inventory than it can afford to manage – if that isn’t already the case. At some point, one hopes, its hunger for more land will be satisfied. The alternative scenario is an ever-expanding number of parks, making an ever-expanding claim on the city’s budget. And let’s not forget that all these acres are permanently removed from the tax rolls.But where is it written that a park or open space must remain a park or open space forever? We don’t look at most other city or county assets that way; why should parks be sacrosanct?Sure, county officials were recently heard threatening to sell off parks in order to meet a budget shortfall. But that was just bluff and bluster, meant to get the public’s attention.Even Boulder has shown a willingness to selectively sell off parcels, when it makes sense to do so. Maybe we should be as open-minded about the possibilities.Why not consider placing some sort of cap on the acreage the city can have in its inventory, either as a sum total or based on some per-capita formula, then require that the city, when it hits the cap, make changes in its inventory through sales and reinvestment or through swaps? Proceeds from the sale of underused or less-desirable parcels could be used to purchase something better, or to maintain and upgrade existing parks. The city could swap less valuable parcels for those it values more. Parcels of less utility or value could be returned to private hands, and to the tax rolls.If the city could use the proceeds from the sale of the relatively nondescript Blue Stem Prairie open space, out by the airport, in order to help pay for the arguably more desirable Section 16, wouldn’t that be a trade-off worth making?Of course, this cap-and-trade (or capand-sell) approach to managing parkland would demand trade-offs. The city would be forced, through this process, to recognize limits, make choices and focus on quality rather than quantity. But that’s part of the problem. Park advocates don’t want to have to choose between the Blue Stem Prairie and Section 16. They want them both; they want them all – even if the city can’t afford to keep feeding their ravenous appetite for more parks.And the city’s parks department doesn’t have to make many hard choices, either, as long as it can convince City Council that parks and open spaces are too politically popular to touch. A steady stream of TOPS revenues and forced land “donations” from developers continually are adding to the city’s land holding, ensuring that the parks department and its budget will need to grow, too. It’s a nice way to ensure job security for parks personnel. But it’s doubtful this can go on forever.What’s proposed wouldn’t mean holding a parks and open space fire sale, or reducing the present inventory of parkland at all. The inventory would continue to grow at a rate commensurate with the population growth (or whatever other formula one chooses). But a cap-and-trade system would help ensure that the city becomes much more selective about the acreage it purchases or acquires – and that the city doesn’t acquire more parkland than it can responsibly manage.-
Paige is executive director of the Limited Government Forum and the editor of www.LocalLibertyonline.org. Write him at sean@limitedgovforum.org.
Dave hartkop, Solar Roast Coffee co-owner, is reflected in a mirror of one of the business’ solar-powered coffee roasters at the Colorado Farm and art Market recently. Photo by (KIRK SPEER, THE GAZETTE)





