Finger pushing


TOWN HALL: We should learn from Canada (poll)

One might say the United States has become Canada’s Mexico. We’re a country to the south with less personal net worth.

That would be an exaggeration, but high-profile results of a study by Environics Analytics of Toronto says the net worth of Canadians has surpassed the net worth of Americans.

The study says the average Canadian household had a net worth of $363,202 at the end of 2011, while the net worth of average American households was only $319,970. It’s about a $44,000 distinction.

Critics of the finding, such as Elizabeth MacDonald writing for Fox Business, says the study failed to account for the 401(k) accounts of Americans. She also complains that Canadians are not burdened with the massive American military budget that keeps Canadians safe.

Fair points, but the fact that Canadians are moving up while Americans stagnate or move downward is cause for concern. If the trend continues, we could, indeed, become Canada’s Mexico.

This column explained in August of 2011, long before the Environics results were released, that American politicians should look to Canada for tips on fixing our economy. Canada has defied the worldwide recession with rising employment and a government surplus.

The magic policy in Canada was less government spending.

“The approach to government largesse that differentiated Canadian policy from that in the rest of the world is now paying dividends as the financial media swoons over Canada’s current fiscal situation,” wrote Canadian banker David Lee, in an article published last year by the Ludwig von Mises Institute. “If there is a lesson to be gleaned from this experience, it is that, whatever the supposed short-term benefits may be, the long-run economic implosion necessitated by rampant government spending can only be delayed, never averted.”

The economy hasn’t always been rosy in Canada. Under the leadership of prime ministers Pierre Trudeau, Brian Mulroney, Jean Chrétien and Paul Martin, national debt increased, government regulations became more intrusive, personal incomes stagnated, health care suffered, personal savings decreased and the value of Canadian currency diminished.

Though they were members of the Liberal Party, Chrétien and Martin saw the failures of uncontrolled government spending. They led the biggest crusade in Canada’s history to reduce spending. In doing so, they helped reverse the country’s massive deficit and managed to preside over $80 billion in surpluses.

Wanting even more fiscal restraint, Canadians in 2006 elected Conservative Stephen Harper as prime minister. In May of 2011 they elected a Conservative majority into Parliament.

“As Republicans and Democrats pushed America further and further to the left and Europe approached ever closer to its socialist ideals, Canada’s political discussion turned from which party could offer the greatest subsidies to the greatest number, to which party’s program of tax cuts would be of more benefit to the economy … For perhaps the first time in its history, Canada finds itself at the most pro-market limit of the political spectrum among the world’s industrialized nations,” wrote Lee.

In December of 2011, the once-progressive Canadian government renounced its cooperation in the United Nation’s Kyoto Protocol — a pact to combat global warming — because it cost too much money.

Despite the evidence of a strong economy, the Conservative government recently announced federal job cuts and other austerity measures, pledging to eliminate their federal deficit of $21 billion by 2016. The U.S. deficit hit $904 billion in June.

If Canadians are doing better than Americans, there’s a reason for it.

Canadians have reduced the size and cost of government as Americans have continued to grow government and spending with a fairy tale wish that it will somehow make us wealthier.

That’s our view, so what’s yours? Please begin or contribute to a Facebook discussion below this article, and vote in the poll to the upper right of here.

Friend editorial page editor Wayne Laugesen on Facebook, follow him on Twitter

Must-see-daily site: Complete Colorado

Photo by
Photo by


Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests