Finger pushing


OUR VIEW: Obamacare decision will chart our future (poll)

Arguments have concluded at the U.S. Supreme Court this week regarding the constitutionality of President Barack Obama’s signature legislation, the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, which we refer to as Obamacare. We were encouraged by the three days of hearings, particularly by some justices’ sharp, skeptical questioning of lawyers supporting and attacking the law. The court will decide whether Congress has the power under the Constitution’s interstate commerce clause to require private individuals to purchase government-approved private health insurance or pay a penalty.

Four liberal justices, appointed by Democratic presidents, are expected to uphold the law. At least three conservative justices, appointed by Republicans, appeared ready to find at least some of the law unconstitutional. There is some question whether Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr., appointed by President George W. Bush, will side with the conservatives, although his questions during the hearings seem to indicate that is likely. Ultimately, upholding or striking down some or all of Obamacare likely rests with the generally moderate Justice Anthony M. Kennedy, appointed in 1988 by President Ronald Reagan and described by the Washington Post as “the justice most likely to side with the court’s liberals.”

It is no exaggeration to say the ruling promises to be a pivotal point in U.S. history. Will government be given a green light to expand even further liberty-killing intrusions into private lives? Or will the court at least slow the trend that has seen freedom increasingly suffer for decades?

For those who believe Obamacare is an unconstitutional expansion of government power, Justice Kennedy gave reason to hope the worst part of the law will be struck down.

“Can you create commerce in order to regulate it?” Kennedy asked government lawyers. He suggested the 2010 law involves a power “beyond what our cases allow” in regulating interstate commerce.

If the Supreme Court scraps Obamacare, will you be happy about the decision? Vote in poll to the right. Must vote to see results.

Moreover, Kennedy said the individual mandate would fundamentally “change the relationship” between government and citizens. Conservative Justice Antonin Scalia was more blunt: “Government is supposed to be a government of limited powers. What is left if the government can do this? What can it not do?”

We agree with the assessment of Timothy Sandefur, attorney for Pacific Legal Foundation, which submitted an amicus curiae brief in the case: “A majority of the justices seem to understand that the individual mandate represents a fundamental change in our constitutional government and an abandonment of our basic principles of limited federal power.”

Government’s role for decades has shifted from protector of rights to provider of benefits. Obamacare is where that statist drift has taken the nation. The health care law imposes literally hundreds of ambiguously worded new requirements, mandates and costs, the fine points of which will be determined by unelected bureaucrats, at the behest of administration political appointees.

As rules are drafted, there will be no end of infringements on individuals’ legitimate rights. We hope the high court reverses this ominous trend to more expansive government and its resultant infringement on true constitutional rights. We optimistically await Justice Kennedy’s swing vote. — From the Orange County Register, a Freedom Communications newspaper.

Tags our view


Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests