Finger pushing


5 Ways to Improve “Arrow”

In the summer of 2012 I was sent a batch TV pilots from The CW network. It contained shows that were to premiere in the fall. There were four series in the set but I only remember one, the pilot for “Arrow.” At the time The CW was a network known primarily for “America’s Next Top Model” and programs that appealed to the YA crowd so the screeners sent to me sat for a month or two.

When I finally got around to watching the “Arrow” pilot, I was blown away. I viewed it about 10 times that summer and even took the disc to New England when I went on vacation so I could watch it with my brother-in-law, who’s an even bigger comic book nerd than myself. I got him hooked on it too. It was just that good. “Arrow” went on to be a hit and its success went way beyond being a pleasant surprise series for The CW.

It may be tough to remember this now, with costumed heroes on TV commonplace and caped vigilantes on movie screens every few months, but “Arrow” did for superhero TV shows what Christopher Nolan’s “Dark Knight” films did for superhero movies. It showcased a formula that could be emulated and proved that series based on comics can be ratings monsters. With the success of “Arrow” TV viewers would end up getting even more comic based programs such as “Marvel’s Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D,” “The Flash,” “Constantine,” “Gotham” and “Daredevil.” And there are more on the way, with Netflix tackling “Jessica Jones” and a new series featuring Iron Fist and Luke Cage, NBC rebooting “Heroes” and the CW spinning off from “Arrow” for a second time with “Legends of Tomorrow.”

All of this comic book TV success can be traced back to “Arrow,” which is why it’s so sad to see the show that helped elevate its own genre become a shell of its former self. After two strong years, the third season of “Arrow” alienated many fans with a bloated cast, an ill-fitting storyline and an over reliance on weak characters (I’m looking at you Laurel Lance and Ra’s al Ghul).

“Arrow” is still an enjoyable but not the great show I fell in love with three years ago. Luckily there is time to change what ails what used to be my favorite comic book TV series (“The Flash” has replaced it). How does “Arrow” turn things around? With these five steps:

1. Trim the cast – There are too many characters on “Arrow” to keep track of so slimming down the list of characters and their individual storylines is a must. We’ve already seen Arsenal (Colton Haynes) leave mysteriously at the end of season three. We also know that Ray Palmer (Brandon Routh) will be leaving to join the cast of “Legends of Tomorrow.” That’s a good start. But chopping down the cast further would be even better. Nyssa al Ghul, Tatsu and Maseo should be taken out completely. With the R’as al Ghul storyline completed, there’s no place for them in “Arrow’s” universe. Other characters who weaken the show are Malcolm Meryln (John Barrowman) and Thea Queen (Willa Holland). Merlyn’s done his part but the character is now learning dangerously close to “Batman ’66” camp. While I’m aware that Thea is supposed to turn into Oliver’s sidekick Speedy, Holland’s combat sequences are ineffective with Roy is an unnecessary distraction. Killing off characters is a ratings grabber so I’d do in Merlyn and have Thea run off with Roy in season four.

2. Go back to Lian Yu – Flashbacks to the island of Lian Yu were so addictive because viewers were able to see Oliver evolve into the Arrow. Oliver didn’t become the badass he is overnight, he was honed into that over five years (which is also why it’s hard to buy Thea, Roy and Laurel as crime fighters). There has to be more stories to tell of his time on the island and season four is when to go back. Ollie’s island stay has been shown as primal, physical and educational. Visits to younger Oliver Queen on Lian Yu worked in seasons one and two. Flashback’s to Amanda Waller giving orders to Oliver in Hong Kong lacked punch.

3. Eliminate the big bad – The formula for a season of “Arrow” has become predictable, especially the finale. In season one, Oliver has a big showdown where he “kills” Malcolm Merlyn. In season two Oliver has a big showdown where he defeats Slade Wilson. In season three Oliver has a big showdown and kills Ra’s al Ghul. We get it, there has to be a season long villain that the Arrow defeats in the final episode. But at this point this formula is too predictable. Its time to shake things up. How about a cliffhanger instead? Leave the audience wondering what happens between Oliver and a bitter rival until the next season starts? Or, how about dividing the season so that several villains have multi-episode story arcs, with the best villain saved for the end? Or, what if Oliver went back to the list of people who did Starling City wrong? You know, the people who failed the city. This would allow the Arrow to get back to his season one roots. Or, how about a mix of all these? A little less predictability would be good.

4. Address the Laurel Lance problem – My biggest issue with “Arrow” is the character of Laurel Lance (Katie Cassidy). “Arrow” showrunners seem to have no idea what to do with her. In season one, her character made sense. She was the heartbroken former love interest who lost both her boyfriend and the sister who ran off with him. I liked Laurel in season one. Then she turned into a Lifetime movie character. Her boyfriend died, she became a DA, she turned into a drunk, she became a vigilante that got beat up all the time, she talked to Nyssa for one episode and became a vigilante that could suddenly hold her own. Come on! Of all the unrealistic things I’ve seen on “Arrow,” the path of Laurel tops the list.

The Black Canary is a big part of Green Arrow canon, so Laurel isn’t going anywhere anytime soon. But this character needs a makeover fast. The best way to do this is to take a page out of “The Flash” playbook and give Ollie and Laurel the will they/won’t they relationship trope that Barry Allen has with Iris West. Yeah, yeah, I know that as of the end of season three, Oliver rode off into the sunset with Felicity. That was showrunners Greg Berlanti and Andrew Kreisberg caving to fan demand to see those two together (the phrase “Olicity” is well known among “Arrow” aficionados) but that’s a mistake. In comics, Green Arrow and Black Canary have a long and complex history. They even get married at one point. An Oliver/Felicity/Laurel love triangle makes sense in season four and would make Laurel a more interesting character. And while we’re at it, someone please teach Katie Cassidy how to throw a punch.

5. Introduce Green Lantern – Throughout this series’ run Oliver has had a number of teammates but no one who could really he could really call an equal. Not even Barry Allen, who as The Flash is more powerful than Oliver. Because of their differences in age and experience, the Green Arrow has been more of a big brother figure to The Flash. Ollie could use a contemporary partner. So far we’ve seen Oliver Queen be a stubborn mule, doing things his own way. This has led to a lot of suffering for his family and his team. A counterpoint to Ollie would not only be another way for the character of Green Arrow to grow, but would also add another layer to the series and who knows, maybe even another spin off.

This is why Green Lantern should join the cast. It’s not like this pairing is without precedence. In the 1970s Green Arrow and Green Lantern co-starred in a line of comics, with each bringing their own contrasting ideas on how to solve the world’s problems. Green Lantern/Hal Jordan could be the yin to Oliver Queen’s yang. Obviously this would require more special effects but if Berlanti and Kreisberg just made him a recurring figure (he would be off planet quite a bit anyway) that would help keep the budget reasonable.



Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests