EDITORIAL: Trump’s ‘anchor baby’ problem
Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump told Fox News the 14th Amendment is, in effect, unconstitutional. He insisted a team of lawyers have told him it won’t hold up to a proper challenge in federal court. Trump reliably escalates a vitriolic challenge to illegal immigration that registers positive enough to make him the GOP’s front-runner of the moment.
The part of the 14th Amendment Trump dislikes guarantees citizenship to anyone born on American turf. It could not be more clear: “All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.”
Given these words are part of the Constitution, and have been since 1868, it is hard to view them as unconstitutional. A federal court’s role is nothing more than weighing the merits of a case against the words and prior interpretations of the Constitution. We don’t want some haute federal judge deciding “persons born” and “citizens of” are complicated phrases subject to lawyerly semantical pettifogging. We know what the definition of “is” is, and someone born in the U.S. is a citizen.
Trump’s claim may have widespread appeal for one obvious reason: The 14th Amendment has become problematic.
Like most rights protected by the Constitution — from gun rights to free speech — natural-born citizenship gets abused. It has become a powerful incentive for people from other countries to come here and/or stay here illegally as a means of giving children they love the benefits of citizenship in a country known for opportunity.
Too many people with legitimate concerns about illegal immigration make the mistake of demonizing kids born here because of unlawful decisions by their parents. Like Trump, they refer to these young Americans as “anchor babies.”
In truth, the problem isn’t the baby — who is statistically likely to become an economic and social asset. The problem is not even the unintended consequence created by the 14th Amendment. Diamonds in the glass case of a jewelry store create an incentive to steal, but we don’t disparage them. Rather, we protect them with elaborate security systems.
There is no problem with the 14th Amendment, which facilitates citizenship that has historically benefited the country. The problem is the 14th Amendment combined with notoriously porous borders and a less-than lackluster effort to enforce immigration laws. The combination makes our country like a jewelry store at night without security cameras, locks and alarms.
We should not distort a precise passage of the Constitution to address a practical problem. Instead, let’s take some of Trump’s other advice — which has been widely advocated by others before him. Let’s secure our borders. Let’s respect and enforce laws that define who belongs here and who does not. Let’s have the political courage and common sense to fix our immigration system.
With proper border security, more sensible laws and the will to use both, we would not resent a sacred right defined in the Constitution for 147 years. We would not hatefully dehumanize innocent young Americans as “anchor babies.” Society would embrace them as humans with dignity, who should grow to improve society. We would continue to advance as a country built of, by and for immigrants and their descendants.
the gazette






