Perspective: Forewarned on abortion
There is perception and then there is reality. Amendment 79 enshrines unrestricted, unregulated abortion into the Colorado state constitution and prohibits anything that might “impede” abortion access. The proponents suggested that this was merely a way to guarantee uninterrupted access to abortion in the future and protect women’s lives. The opponents warned of the impact on parental rights, women’s health/safety, fetal rights, and the state budget. Now that it has passed, what is the reality? Coloradans need to be aware of how 79 changes the abortion status quo and anticipate the inevitable consequences.
One of the only existing abortion regulations in Colorado was the requirement for parental notification (but not consent) prior to a minor teen’s abortion. Proponents claimed that parental notification would not be affected by 79. Dani Newsum, the designated representative for Amendment 79, was among the advocates who repeatedly stated that the measure had nothing to do with eliminating current Colorado notification laws. An important detail was left unsaid. The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) is a professional medical organization that advocates for abortion rights. It also is the organization that courts use to assess the standard of care for the practice of OB. ACOG has issued a committee report stating parental involvement “impedes” access to abortion.
Pro-abortion legislators may feel restrained by the campaign rhetoric and avoid passing legislation to repeal parental notification. However, the courts will not feel this same reluctance. Parental notification will be the victim of a legal challenge made possible by 79. The courts will rely on ACOG and the abortion industry to define what “impedes” abortion access.
Without parental notification, our daughters could face a life-altering decision without the counseling and support from the people who know and love them the most. Furthermore, the ability to identify teens who are being sex trafficked and undergoing coerced abortions will be compromised.
Abortion redefined
One of the most potent arguments for 79 was the claim that women’s lives would be protected by the measure. By redefining abortion as “health care” and falsely conflating elective induced abortions with miscarriage care, treatment of ectopic pregnancies, treatment for medical complications of pregnancy, and management of pregnancies with life-limiting fetal diagnoses, 79 supporters were able to convince a supermajority of the electorate to support the constitutional amendment. This was abetted by sympathetic national and local media coverage of the issue. But how does this perception comport with reality?
A miscarriage, commonly referred to as a spontaneous abortion in medical literature, is nothing like an elective induced abortion. In a miscarriage, the embryo or fetus dies naturally in the uterus and the remains are passed vaginally. During an induced abortion, the embryo or fetus is intentionally killed by the abortion provider before being removed either medically or surgically. The same drugs (mifepristone/misoprostol) or procedures (D&C/D&E) utilized for an induced abortion are sometimes used to ensure the complete passage of the fetal/placental tissue following a miscarriage or stillbirth. However, using the same drugs or procedures does not transform a miscarriage into an elective induced abortion. This is why restrictions enacted to reduce elective induced abortions have no bearing on the treatment for miscarriage. Whether or not 79 passed, women would always have access to compassionate miscarriage care.
During the campaign for 79, on advocate claimed that those who suffered from life-threatening pregnancy complications during a pregnancy such as hers (previable premature rupture of membranes or PPROM) would not have guaranteed access to compassionate, medically indicated abortion in Colorado. Even ignoring the improving outcomes documented for women experiencing PPROM, this simply is not accurate. Abortion restrictions don’t prohibit interventions for complications of pregnancy that place a woman’s life at risk based on “reasonable medical judgement” or “good faith judgement.” Death doesn’t have to be “imminent” as some have suggested. Medically indicated abortion would include premature delivery of the fetus for PPROM if that were the mother’s choice — anywhere in the country.
The issue of medically indicated abortion has caused much confusion since anti-abortion and pro-abortion physicians often use different terminology to describe the same thing. Many anti-abortion advocates avoid the term “abortion” altogether and refer to an intervention to save the life of the mother as a “separation” or simply “premature delivery.” They often say “abortion” is never necessary. Regardless, it should be easy to differentiate a medically indicated abortion from an elective induced abortion. In the former, the pregnancy is terminated prematurely to prevent the mother’s death or irreversible bodily harm which can’t be mitigated in any other way to save both lives. The death of the fetus is the unintentional, if not predictable, result of the procedure. There is no need to directly harm the fetus, such as injecting a feticide or dismembering the fetus (as is common in elective induced abortions). In the latter, the pregnancy is terminated with the expressed intent to kill the developing human with no regard for the pain or suffering endured by the developing fetus.
Safety imperiled
In a several articles, undoubtedly timed to have the most electoral impact, journalists in some media sowed fear regarding the alleged impact of abortion regulation and the need to constitutionalize abortion access. ProPublica published a case series that was referenced by Kamala Harris and supporters of 79 here in Colorado. It purported to demonstrate the lethal harm caused by the institution of abortion restrictions. However, it takes only a rudimentary knowledge of the management of pregnancy complications to see that these tragic cases were not the result of abortion restrictions implemented post Dobbs. These women’s accounts should have been the basis for banner headlines and stories debunking the fantasy that the medication abortion pills are “safer than Tylenol.”
Amber Thurman’s story best illustrates this false narrative. She died from life-threatening infectious complications from a medication abortion obtained in North Carolina coupled with medical negligence in Georgia. Candi Miller died after taking mail order abortion pills which the abortion industry promotes as “safe and effective.” She experienced an incomplete abortion and suffered severe disabling pain at home in Georgia before overdosing on fentanyl. Contrary to the media spin, these cases support the arguments against 79. By promoting unregulated, unrestricted abortion, Amendment 79 will increase the probability that lethal complications of medication abortions like these will occur — in Colorado women as well as those who travel from other states for their abortion.
Amendment 79 won’t change the status quo regarding state oversight of high-risk second and third trimester abortion clinics — because there is no oversight. However, by placing abortion in the Colorado Bill of Rights, the ability of state government and legislators to develop prudent health and safety regulations in the future would be severely curtailed.
Second and third trimester abortion clinics are not licensed, regulated or inspected in Colorado despite at least a 10% complication rate and 1.7% life-threatening complication rate. There is no mechanism to enforce standards of sanitation, disease prevention protocols, or standardized evidence-based clinical guidelines. There is no way to ensure the availability of ultrasound to prevent complications before/after a planned abortion procedure or emergency equipment to deal with hemorrhage and other life-threatening complications. Some “good” abortion providers will incorporate these into their practice without oversight but there is no way to separate them from the “bad” abortion providers who simply care about their financial remuneration from abortion. Abortionists are now flocking to Colorado from states with abortion restrictions because of the lack of regulation and legislative protection from malpractice that Colorado has established.
Abortion clinic regulations are deemed an impediment to abortion access by ACOG and other professional medical organizations who have an inherent conflict of interest because of their flagrant abortion advocacy. This poses the real risk to women’s health because 79 prohibits anything that “impedes” access to abortion. Even if legislators felt compelled to institute basic health/safety regulations for abortion clinics after a series of women experienced life-threatening complications in unregulated clinics, the courts will again defer to ACOG in any suit filed by the abortion industry. Colorado women will be at high risk for preventable morbidity and mortality because of Amendment 79.
Whether there would be abortion access throughout pregnancy was never at issue in the 79 debate. Abortion at any time for any reason was already the law of the land. However, with 79 in place, Coloradans can never make legislative course corrections to restrict abortions — even when there is a broad public consensus.
Few people realize that there are approximately 500 abortions performed after the lower limit of fetal viability in Colorado each year and even fewer are aware that the majority of these abortions are performed on healthy women with healthy babies. These fetuses are babies who are fully human and could survive independently if born prematurely. Amendment 79 removes all fetal considerations by declaring that there isn’t any time during pregnancy that fetuses could be protected — even late in the third trimester. Killing these babies for the financial or social issues confronting their mothers is not compassionate. Virtually every Coloradan I know when confronted with the grim reality of post-viable abortions on healthy women carrying healthy babies would choose to restrict these abortions and offer women tangible alternatives. The people of Colorado will no longer have that option with 79 in our constitution.
Fiscal toll
The only other existing restriction on abortion in Colorado has been public financing. Public funding for medically indicated abortions and following rape have been permitted in Colorado for decades. However, Amendment 3, which was passed in 1984, prohibited public funding for elective induced abortions.
The Colorado Blue Book for Amendment 79 stated that the measure would rescind the restrictions on public funding for elective abortions but have “no fiscal impact to state and local governments.” Nothing could be further from the truth.
One of the expressed purposes of 79 was to expand state subsidized elective induced abortion in state employee health plans and for recipients of state Medicaid. In states that have authorized public funding for elective abortion, the fiscal impact has been in the millions of dollars. In a cash strapped 2025 state budget, we will be diverting critical taxpayer dollars from high priority areas to pay for elective induced abortion.
Proponents of Amendment 79 made arguments that don’t reflect reality. Opponents of Amendment 79 warned the public about the negative impacts of the measure on parental involvement, women’s health/safety, fetal rights and the state budget.
Opponents will take no pleasure as these consequences unfold. We only hope that as the adverse consequences of Amendment 79 are revealed, the media and public pay attention.
Frances Rossi and Tom Perille, M.D., are founding members of Democrats for Life of Colorado.







