Finger pushing


Perspective: Rail vs. reality

Have you noticed that the expansion of passenger rail is beginning to permeate agendas of state and local governments? The romance of big rail projects and access to other people’s money have always been hard for career politicians to resist.

Gov. Jared Polis is no different. The Biden administration is dangling billions of federal taxpayer dollars out for grabs. Here at home, the governor just secured a legislated $3-per-day rental car fee worth $58 million per year and a privately negotiated political ransom worth $175 million per year from Colorado oil and gas producers in the form of new production fees that will be funneled toward new passenger rail initiatives.

Polis’ message to our local governments seems to be “all aboard!” or get out of the way. However, his aspiration to make passenger rail mainstream in Colorado is totally separated from economic and logistical reality for families, woefully misjudges the feasibility of such an option for the viability of local businesses across the state and will misallocate dollars that could have been spent elsewhere to reduce significantly greater amounts of greenhouse gas emissions.

Real-world examples provide convincing evidence.

Transit’s toll

Let’s start with the desperate state of affairs at the Denver area’s RTD, where fares from passenger rail represent about half of fares collected. Unfortunately, customer fares across the RTD system cover less than 5% of operating costs, according to RTD’s most recent monthly financial report. Taxpayers are left to fill the gaping hole. One would think that a “95% off sale” would boost demand for any product. But consumers are quite adept at weighing out-of-pocket costs against the value derived in their daily lives.

Taxpayers aren’t so lucky. Even when giving their service away for free — as RTD did during its Zero Fare for Better Air campaign in July and August last year — demand for rides increased a measly 10% compared with the same months in 2022. After the program ended, ridership immediately reverted to prior levels, which remain nearly 40% below pre-COVID levels.

RTD is not delivering a product that competes on quality or cost — for riders, taxpayers, or the benefit of our environment. According to its most recent annual financial statements and passenger miles collected by the U.S. Federal Transportation Administration, RTD’s operating cost to move each passenger one mile was an astonishing $2.88 in 2022. For context, the cost of mobility delivered by RTD was nearly five times the 2022 mileage reimbursement rate allowed by the IRS for the business use of your car.

How effective is RTD in spending taxpayer dollars to reduce greenhouse gas emissions? The previously mentioned Zero Fare for Better Air campaign offers a clue. RTD estimated that the temporary increase in ridership avoided 6.1 million pounds of greenhouse gas emissions at a cost of $16 million in foregone fares and other program expenses which were borne 100% by taxpayers.

The Zero Fare for Better Air program’s implied cost of carbon emissions avoided works out to a lofty $5,600 per ton. Meanwhile, California’s cap-and-trade program priced carbon emissions at $30 per ton in 2023.

Estimates from Goldman Sachs suggest that transportation is the most expensive sector to decarbonize, but their analysis of various investments to do so peg costs that range from less than $100 to $800 per ton. Pouring additional billions of taxpayer dollars into RTD for rail expansion is akin to investment malpractice whether your primary goal is flexible, low-cost mobility or funding projects that will maximize greenhouse gas emissions reductions.

Rail’s real cost

Another real-world case that is near and dear to the hearts of many in Colorado — the Amtrak ski train, which runs between Union Station in Denver and Winter Park on peak ski weekends. Polis has recently become fond of the ski train and believes passenger service to Winter Park should be expanded and extended to serve Steamboat Springs and Craig as a part of northwest Colorado’s “just transition” away from coal. To be sure, there is a legitimate concern that the absence of coal traffic on the Union Pacific line that serves northwest Colorado will render the track economically obsolete. However, throwing a passenger rail Hail Mary without significant freight traffic to replace coal is likely to prove futile.

Consider the ski season just ended. The Winter Park ski train ran 38 days on peak weekends (Amtrak intended to run 40 days but a mudslide and a severe storm otherwise known as an epic powder day canceled the train twice). Average seat capacity was 281 per day, and average riders totaled 221 per day.

The most recent Winter Park Resort Master Development Plan quotes current peak day capacity of more than 17,200 visitors and nearly 23,700 visitors if the planned territory expansion and Town Gondola are completed. Therefore, current ski train riders represent about 1% of the visitors that Winter Park Resort and local businesses require on peak weekends to be sustainable. How many trains is the governor planning to run to deliver meaningful numbers of visitors to Winter Park, much less the additional numbers required by Steamboat?

Why didn’t more people ride the ski train this season? Ponder the economics for a family of four. Operating at a significantly different price point and revenue model compared to RTD, Amtrak’s ski train tickets for two adults and two kids cost $177. Parking the family car at Union Station is another $58 per day for a roundtrip cost of $235.

Alternatively, the cost of independent driving is estimated at $91, assuming the family car gets 25 mpg (at average February gas prices), 20 cents per mile to account for wear and tear, and $50 for primo covered parking at the resort. So, the net premium of riding the ski train vs. driving comes to just over $144 per trip. The ski train is a splurge — very few families would elect the train on a regular basis. In fact, the gas price required to inflate the cost of driving to be equivalent with the cost of riding the ski train for this family is a whopping $30.52 per gallon.

Not so green

What about the ski train’s impact on the planet? An open records request to Amtrak provided the ridership stats above but was unsuccessful in extracting the volume of diesel burned by the ski train this winter. Amtrak initially claimed the ski train’s fuel consumption was a trade secret and exempt from open records requests. When pressed, they later claimed fuel volumes were not tracked — no joke.

However, using the average emissions per seat mile for Amtrak’s diesel fleet as reported in their latest sustainability report, we can estimate that this family’s carbon footprint was lowered by 6% or 0.0028 tons of CO2 by riding the ski train vs driving independently. The implied cost (net premium paid to ride the train) of carbon emissions avoided was a staggering $52,000 per ton. Given the average American is responsible for 19 tons of greenhouse gas emissions per year, pursuing decarbonization goals at ski train costs will quickly bankrupt us all.

I love that Winter Park has the novelty of the ski train — it’s a unique experience for riders and a great marketing tool for the resort. It’s also a two-hour trip with an average speed of 30 mph. And while mountain bikers across Colorado will go out of their way to ride a great single-track — trying to move thousands of weekend skiers on the single rail track that cuts through 29 Front Range tunnels, burrows under the Continental Divide via the iconic 6-mile Moffat Tunnel, and hugs the walls of multiple canyons along the circuitous route in time for a first chair at either Winter Park or Steamboat is a fantasy.

Freedom enabled by independent mobility is central to quality of life and economic opportunity in Colorado. Passenger rail has massive cost and convenience gaps to close for it to be considered a mainstream mode of transportation, a cost-effective tool to lower greenhouse gas emissions, or a viable means of creating a “just transition” for northwest Colorado. Any politician claiming otherwise cannot be trusted.

Ryan Zorn is a Colorado native, Colorado School of Mines graduate and a resident of Fraser. He recently joined Liberty Energy as director of energy additions. He is a contributor to Liberty’s Bettering Human Lives publication and assists the company with its investments in modular power solutions, advanced geothermal, small modular reactors and emerging battery technology.

Ryan Zorn
Ryan Zorn
The Moffat Tunnel is a railroad and water tunnel that cuts through the Continental Divide in north-central Colorado. (Courtesy of Winter Park Resort)
The Moffat Tunnel is a railroad and water tunnel that cuts through the Continental Divide in north-central Colorado. (Courtesy of Winter Park Resort)
Tags columnists

Ryan Zorn

Reporter


Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests