Finger pushing


Abortion overkill

What would it mean if the only medical intervention that is recognized in the Colorado Constitution’s Bill of Rights was abortion?

And what would it mean if abortion was the only medical intervention that couldn’t be constitutionally excluded in private and public health insurance? Not access to basic medical care. Not pregnancy care. Not life-saving cancer treatments. Not mental health treatment. Not care for those who are addicted. Not affordable pharmaceuticals. Only abortion. That is what those who are pushing Amendment 79 (“Right to Abortion”) hope to accomplish.

Not only would abortion at any time in pregnancy for any reason using any method become a fundamental right, but anything that “impeded” or “discriminated” against access to abortion would be prohibited.

The people of Colorado have a right to know the profound and dangerous implications of such a measure — which won’t be reflected in the official description of the measure in the Blue Book ballot guide distributed to voters.

In a poll conducted in July by the Strategy Group, 71% of Colorado voters were unaware that abortion is currently legal under all circumstances in our state. Abortion access is guaranteed in Colorado law. Amendment 79 would do nothing to change that reality. Coloradans have the right to know that with the amendment in the constitution, the people of Colorado and those working for them in the legislature could do nothing to regulate or restrict abortion in the future — even if those changes represented the overwhelming consensus of Coloradans and protected the health and safety of women.

There were between 468 and 486 late abortions after the limit of fetal viability (21 weeks) reported to the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment in 2022 and 2023. Guttmacher estimates that there were 71% more abortions in 2023 than CDPHE reported, making 500 a conservative estimate of the total number of post-viability abortions each year in Colorado. These babies can “kick” their mother, respond to her voice/touch, acquire her taste preferences, and feel pain while in the uterus. They can survive if born prematurely. Babies born at 22 weeks and later can be found lovingly cared for in neonatal intensive care units and nurseries across the state.

Based on research from Boulder abortionist Warren Hern, 70% of his late abortions are performed on healthy women with healthy babies. That translates into an estimated 350 healthy babies aborted late in pregnancy each year in Colorado for financial and social reasons. Coloradans have the right to know that Amendment 79 does nothing to address the real needs of these women and simply streamlines access to one, tragic and regrettable choice. With Amendment 79 in place, legislators would be unable to restrict even the most extreme abortions on healthy women with healthy babies in the third trimester.

Colorado parents are currently notified at least 48 hours in advance of their minor teen’s pending abortion. The abortion industry, their research allies (Guttmacher), and aligned medical professional organizations (ACOG) all consider parental notification before a minor teen’s abortion to be an impediment to abortion access. Coloradans have the right to know that banning parental notification would be one of the most immediate consequences of Amendment 79. In practical terms, this means that the people who know and love the teen the most may be unaware of their pending abortion and unable to support their daughter. Even worse, teens may be pressured by peers or an abortion clinic counselor to pursue an action that is inconsistent with their wishes and core values. Parents may be blindsided by the potentially severe physical and mental health consequences of their teen’s abortion. And sex traffickers would be able to hide their nefarious trade by pursuing abortions for their teenage victims without the safeguard of parental notification.

Trafficking is a multimillion-dollar criminal enterprise in Colorado. Victims rarely self-identify. Anyone who works with domestic minor sex trafficking knows that the very definition of trafficking involves force, fraud and/or coercion. It is also well known that girls who are trafficked often view their trafficker as their “boyfriend,” lacking the maturity and discernment to know they are being trafficked and in danger. If they refuse to do what the trafficker wants, they are often subject to physical and mental abuse until they submit. There is a growing concern over forced abortion, especially with the availability of medication and telehealth abortions. These girls are not free to choose.

Without the safeguard of parental notification, minors may be exposed to continued risk. Keep in mind, minors can be brought across state borders by anyone for abortion, just to be released back to the trafficker/perpetrator.

For this reason, parents have a right to know when their daughter is considering abortion so that they can seek help and intervene.

Most states have regulations that pertain to abortion clinics and promote the health and safety of women. Colorado is not one of them. The abortion industry pejoratively refers to any regulation that specifically applies to abortion providers as TRAP laws. They view them as impediments to abortion access. Even though thousands of medical facilities and agencies are licensed, regulated and inspected by the state health department, second- and third-trimester abortion clinics are the glaring exception. This omission is especially perplexing since second-trimester abortions have a 10% overall complication rate and 1.7% life-threatening complication rate. The risk of having a complication increases for each additional week of gestation. Furthermore, the risk of dying from an abortion increases 38% for each week of gestation beyond eight weeks. We should heed the lesson from other states that have tragically witnessed the maiming and death of women when government oversight is lax or non-existent — as in the Gosnell case in Pennsylvania.

Coloradans have a right to know that if Amendment 79 passes, the state will be unable to impose prudent health and safety regulations for abortion clinics which may jeopardize women’s health and lives.

Another goal of Amendment 79 is to facilitate publicly funded abortions. Currently, Colorado Medicaid only pays for abortions in circumstances of rape, incest, and threats to the life of the mother. If Amendment 79 passes, the prohibition against public funding in the constitution will be removed and the state will be able to underwrite elective abortions for Medicaid patients. In states where public funding for abortion is already law, they spend millions of dollars subsidizing abortion for in-state and out-of-state women. Coloradans have the right to know that this may take precious tax dollars away from other medical priorities like pregnancy services and mental health. It may even divert money from non-medical budgets for education, affordable housing, and the environment.

There is already inadequate private and public support for pregnant women in our state. One of the few shining exceptions is the 58 pregnancy resource centers. They provide millions of dollars of uncompensated care to women during and after challenging pregnancies. However, because they typically don’t offer abortion services or refer for abortions, the abortion industry has been targeting these charitable organizations.

Coloradans have the right to know that the ability of pregnancy resource centers to assist pregnant women in need may be jeopardized by the passage of Amendment 79.

Under Amendment 79, the right to abortion would become absolute. Coloradans have the right to know the implications of such an extreme position. It would strip all rights and protections from the developing fetus, even those that are wanted. The legislature couldn’t prohibit abortion methods that are especially cruel such as second trimester D&E (dismemberment) abortions on pain-capable fetuses. It would jeopardize the conscientious rights of medical professionals across the state who maintain medical/scientific, moral or religious objections to elective induced abortions. Since the amendment forbids “discriminating” against a woman’s desire for an abortion, even physicians and nurse practitioners who perform abortions would be unable to refuse abortions for reasons they may view as morally repugnant – such as aborting a fetus solely because of their sex (which is already occurring) or because of the ethnicity/race of their father.

Abortion access is already guaranteed in Colorado law. Making the right to abortion the only medical procedure recognized in our constitution is extreme and ties the hands of Colorado citizens and legislators. It goes far beyond the abortion rights promulgated in the Roe decision.

Coloradans have the right to know that Amendment 79 would have these many unintended consequences. Given the facts, we hope that Coloradans reject Amendment 79.

Tom Perille, M.D., and Wendy J. Smith, a retired acute care nurse practitioner, are founding members of AAPLOG Colorado (American Association of Prolife Obstetricians and Gynecologists) along with Catherine Wheeler, M.D., OB/GYN. Perille is a retired hospital medicine specialist and is president of Democrats for Life of Colorado. Wendy Smith specialized in hematology/oncology and currently volunteers with three anti-trafficking organizations with a focus on domestic minor sex trafficking. She has spent more than 18 years volunteering in prisons.

Mug - Wendy Smith
Mug – Wendy Smith
Mug - Tom Perille
Mug – Tom Perille
Rep. Matt Soper, R-Delta, addresses anti- abortion protesters outside the Capitol in Denver in April for a rally urging Gov. Jared Polis to veto a package of abortion- rights bills. (THE DENVER GAZETTE)
Rep. Matt Soper, R-Delta, addresses anti- abortion protesters outside the Capitol in Denver in April for a rally urging Gov. Jared Polis to veto a package of abortion- rights bills. (THE DENVER GAZETTE)
Abortion-rights activists hold signs and protest May 14, 2022, in Edwards. (Chris Dillmann, Vail Daily via AP, File)
Abortion-rights activists hold signs and protest May 14, 2022, in Edwards. (Chris Dillmann, Vail Daily via AP, File)
Tags columnists


Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests