Finger pushing


PERSPECTIVE: Power shift

The U.S. Supreme Court finally is restoring some of the balance of power back to the Constitution. Just last month, the court issued three rulings on federal power that will prove much more explosive than people expect. Their combined effect will restore power to the people and reduce government intrusion in our lives by limiting the power of the administrative state.

The bloat in Washington is worse than we often recognize. The federal government spent $4.49 trillion this year, employing 3 million federal workers across more than 400 agencies and organizations.

They are busy little bees. The number of regulations grows nearly every year. The Federal Register (the daily digest of agency actions) tripled from 1964-75 and doubled again to almost 100,000 pages by 2016, the last year of the Obama administration. That regulation costs taxpayers and businesses more than $3 trillion a year in compliance costs.

These new legal decisions change all that.

Bad precedent

Congress often passes laws using vague language; they know what their goal is but not necessarily how to accomplish it. Starting with the original Chevron v. Natural Resources Defense Council decision in 1984, courts have deferred to the expertise of federal agencies in clarifying vague language — agencies which frequently expand the definition and scope far beyond its legislative intent, thereby growing their own power. That became known as the principle of “Chevron deference,” or “the tie goes to the runner,” said Matthew Groves, attorney and president and CEO of the Colorado Automobile Dealers Association.

Independence Institute constitutional scholar Rob Natelson calls this a “fundamentally immoral situation, where the court puts its thumb on the scales against citizens. Agencies’ lawyers and specialists, paid for by taxpayers, vs. the individual citizen or business, who must pay for their own defense. They stack the deck against you even more by assuming the agencies are correct.”

In last month’s Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo decision, the 6-3 majority ruled that Chevron deference conflicts with the founding principle of separation of powers clearly established in the Constitution. The court determined that “courts, not agencies, will decide ‘all relevant questions of law’ arising on review of agency action.”

In plain terms, that means that federal agencies and the political appointees who oversee them cannot decide what they think a law means.

“Courts must exercise their independent judgment in deciding whether an agency has acted within its statutory authority” and “may not defer to an agency interpretation of the law simply because a statute is ambiguous.”

For years, any regulation could only be challenged for six years from the date it went into effect, essentially making it permanent and immune to challenge. The decision in Corner Post, Inc. v. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System now gives injured parties six years to challenge or appeal a decision from the date they are injured.

That is an enormous restoration of constitutional rights to the people, although Groves suggests that it opens a Pandora’s Box for future legal appeals to overwhelm the court system.

Finally, the court decided in Securities and Exchange Commission v. Jarkesy that citizens have the right to a jury trial under the 7th Amendment when they are ordered to pay civil penalties by a wide range of administrative agencies beyond just the SEC. A single administrative law judge no longer can impose penalties as they see fit.

Greg Walcher, former head of the Colorado Department of Natural Resources, said “The court has now declared that it’s time for both the judicial and legislative branches to do their jobs and stop letting unelected — and often unnamed — agency officials run the country.”

Federal realignment

These decisions fundamentally reverse the long shift in the power of the federal government away from the legislative branch, which began in the early 1900’s. The Loper decision is clear that federal courts have the fundamental responsibility for interpreting federal statutes, not agencies. This will increase the size and power of the courts, which may or may not be a good thing.

Congress — the most important branch of government in the Constitution — will be forced to reclaim significant authority it has delegated to the executive branch. Legislators will have to be more specific in their language and will need to rely more on outside experts, from think tanks to trade associations to nonprofits.

Finally, the executive branch will undergo big changes. Agencies will have to be more cautious in rule making and interpreting statutes. Further, the overturn of large swaths of an agency’s rules could lead to downsizing the agency and reducing its importance. That is not bad news at all.

Colorado impact

To be clear, the SCOTUS decisions apply to federal agencies and not to the states. Federal regulations set a baseline standard, but in many cases, states impose tighter regulations, such as California’s vehicle emissions standards.

Where areas of federal regulation are challenged in future years, big blue states like California and New York will likely grow in power, as their rules set the precedent for many others including Colorado.

One of the biggest impacts of the Chevron reversal in Colorado might be on EPA mandates. The oil and gas industry in particular faces tough federal regulation and enforcement.

The EPA frequently issues “guidance” that it creates when Congress is unclear. Regulation based on such “guidance” and not authorized by Congress is “ripe for a challenge without Chevron protections,” says Patrick Davis, a former EPA and White House official.

As an example of what could happen thanks to the Loper decision, the Supreme Court recently agreed to hear a case supported by the Mountain States Legal Foundation to limit over-broad applications of the National Environmental Policy Act. In Seven County Infrastructure Coalition v. Eagle County, Colorado, the Mountain States Legal Foundation is arguing that a regional authority cannot misinterpret and weaponize federal law on other subjects to block a transportation project.

Ivan London, lead attorney in the case, said, “We are optimistic that we can help the court explain that the long-time abuse of NEPA in the federal courts must stop.”

Other federal regulations impact Colorado businesses by raising the cost of doing business, from taxes to hiring policies, workplace safety and accessibility, and more. Even if affected parties challenge these regulations, states likely will step up their regulatory schemes to fill in gaps.

It’s also unlikely that Colorado regulations will be overturned any time soon. With continued majorities and supermajorities in the Legislature, and with an appeals court system stacked with Democratic appointees, it will be difficult for any legal challenge to succeed.

There is a real danger here for Colorado. We are becoming a poor state to do business in, even as the Legislature and governor impose hosts of new regulations.

In a recent survey of CEOs on the best states in which to do business, Colorado dropped 16 spots — in one year! — from 13th to 29th. Expansive new state regulations in the post-Chevron environment will only make it more likely that companies and jobs flee the state.

These Supreme Court decisions are neither conservative nor liberal. But for the past 80 years, the executive branch agencies and the Supreme Court have been dominated by the left. They have advanced many of their cherished progressive goals by weaponizing the agencies and the courts. The Roberts Court is pulling hard on the reins of a runaway federal bureaucracy.

Groves concluded: “The court is not creating new rights, or overturning any laws passed by Congress, it is just overturning the court’s own activist precedents. They are telling Congress it has to do its job.”

Tom Copeland, Ph.D., is the director of research at the Centennial Institute of Colorado Christian University. He writes regularly on public policy and the intersection of politics, culture and religion. The views expressed by the author are his own and do not represent the views of Centennial Institute or Colorado Christian University.

Mug - Tom Copeland
Mug – Tom Copeland
Themis court justice scales (Getty Images)
Themis court justice scales (Getty Images)
Supreme Court building Washington DC (Getty Images)
Supreme Court building Washington DC (Getty Images)
power shift
power shift
Tags columnists


Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests