Finger pushing


Perspective:Using guns to drive a wedge

Unfortunately, both sides of the political divide are using guns as a political weapon to frighten and divide Coloradans, and all Americans. The more partisan the division in a district, the bigger a role ideology plays – predictably on one side or the other. Democratic strongholds will push any provision that is “anti-gun.” The opposite is true in areas solidly controlled by Republicans.

We must all ask why. Constitutional rights, after all, belong to all Americans regardless of their political affiliation. The founders mistrusted political factions. They had seen the danger in one faction punishing those with other culture and belief systems. That is precisely why the United States Constitution emphasizes individual, not collective, rights.

But division is a powerful political tool. “Wedge” issues are used to first divide and then consolidate predictable voting blocs — always pushing the extremes. These issues are frequently argued but rarely solved. They are persistent and divisive. That “bug” is the feature. Over the last several decades, politicos embraced the fear, passion and power that could be leveraged in the gun debate.

Colorado is currently center stage for this cultural fight. Colorado’s politics changed as its demographics shifted. Predictable talking points have followed. Democratic influence has gone up in Colorado’s more urbanized centers. Colorado’s suburban and rural areas have remained predictably more conservative. As political parties have become more polarized (both further from center) they have embraced the “gunfight.”

It’s an easy wedge issue because each side’s preferred solutions generally target the other side’s political constituency. Laws that negatively impact the legal commerce, ownership and use of firearms disproportionately impact only those involved legally in the same — mostly Republicans. If you aren’t a legal owner, you tend not to care. The “go hard on the crime” angle disproportionately impacts people near large urban centers — mostly Democrats. If you don’t have people you know negatively impacted, you tend to not care. In the middle are scared people largely unaffected by daily impacts but who are asked by either side to imagine they are impacted in the most dramatic ways.

Each side tells Coloradans the other side is bad, wrong — or worse, they are evil. Both sides can find statistics to match their arguments. For example, hundreds of mass shootings per year are reported nationwide (if counted a certain way), but there is reluctance to admit that they are overwhelmingly criminals illegally possessing firearms in Democratic strongholds. Republicans counter that mass shootings (classified differently) are most prevalent in “gun-free” zones — but they are counting only the specific subsets in certain public spaces; ignoring the hundreds that occurred at house parties or as the result of a domestic dispute.

There are more statistics to choose from. Republicans and the FBI truthfully say so-called “assault rifles” are used in less than 3% of violent crimes. But gun-control advocates and “progressives” point to the trend of undefined “assault weapons” being more common in many extreme events that generate the most attention. Definitions matter. Long guns of all types are rarely used in violent crimes. But sociopaths who commit the most violent, senseless, crimes often use every weapon at their disposal to do so. Many things can be true at once.

Most of the solutions proposed have avoided not only the common ground, but also the fertile ground — the places where you can make a statistical difference, a real solution. Little to no effort is made to engage the other side in a constructive, respectful dialogue; to understand the other side’s perspectives and beliefs, to inform and teach. More importantly, the pragmatic solutions that would calm the arguments are avoided because they lack the “wow” factor that partisans crave. It seems the endgame is to gain power, not achieve good policy outcomes within the framework of the Constitution.

There are notable exceptions. Some “true believers” come to their positions understandably and honestly. They have personal scars. The best of us reach out for more understanding. Other elected officials sit in districts that swing from one election to another. They know that grandstanding often means a short career.

Good leaders have the ability to see the other side. They are disinterested in extreme proposals that pander to the most ardent voices. They want balance because that is where most Americans actually sit politically — in the middle. They know that they must consider not just their faction but also the individual rights of a person who isn’t on their team. The law cannot be “just good for me”.

A stable democracy needs to be governed in the middle. Otherwise, the factions our founders feared become tools that undermine not just the collective peace, but the most basic rights of individuals who don’t belong to the faction.

This isn’t about guns. The gun is just a totem. The argument could be over shovels. Millions of dollars are raised and spent by the far left and far right to leverage similar issues for political gain. The gun is just a fitting metaphor to attack and harm people who don’t believe the same things.

This year in Colorado we saw the unacceptable: personal attacks shared on social media targeting legislators and staffers — a “pro-gun” group sensationalizing the process to gain “clicks.” They turn policy disagreements into personal attacks. On the other side of the aisle are progressive legislators, standing in the Capitol, shouting insults and heckling peaceful protesters gathered outside. Inside the committees “gun control” zealots called “anyone opposed” to their positions complicit as “child killers.” We have seen the worst of us.

It is time to stop. The far left and far right are more like one another than they are like mainstream Coloradans. Their intolerance, insistence on “purity,” lack of empathy or desire for understanding are mirror images of one another.

People who have been impacted by violence, including gun violence, deserve sympathy, compassion, and an effort to understand their motivations and fears. Publicly assaulting these victims is pathetic, juvenile, and small-minded. It is wrong. They may not understand firearms, but it is easy to understand why they feel as they do. You can’t explain away their fear. You can help them find solutions for it. Those imperfect solutions won’t be where they start – but it may be where you finish.

Similarly, to look down on the motive or intelligence of Colorado citizens who would choose to exercise the right to keep and bear arms safely and legally demonstrates great hubris. When you cannot articulate the details of the requirement you would impose; you have no expertise to understand the intricacies and impacts of what you would ban; you neither own nor can understand “why” someone needs to — you are the one guilty of ignorance. It isn’t ours to question the “why” in someone else’s exercise of rights. They get that choice.

We don’t have to think like each other. But we do have to live with each other. We must seek the middle.

It is time for Colorado to stop surrendering the public discourse to the fringes. People unable to control their tongue or their social media feed have no place in the driver’s seat of Colorado politics. Those who hijack government for personal celebrity are unfit stewards of public trust. We can and must do better.

Nephi Cole is the director of government relations–state affairs for NSSF, The Firearm Trade Industry Trade Association.

Nephi Cole
Nephi Cole
Tags columnists


Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests