Perspective: Higher-ed disconnect
Colorado is facing real economic issues growing from its housing affordability problems, aftershocks in public safety perception, slowing jobs growth and declining taxable retail sales. The plan to address these issues would be incomplete without a robust strategy to produce its homegrown workers.
That’s where Colorado’s higher education system should come in.
Historically, Colorado’s institutions of higher education have demonstrated relative efficiency in aligning some academic programs with the state’s evolving workforce demands. For example, some of the state’s most in-demand industries are a priority for many Colorado institutions.
Take health professions, which accounted for 105,050 graduates between 2001 and 2021. Among these occupations, the University of Colorado Denver and Front Range Community College accounted for the largest share of graduates, with 14,887 and 14,444, respectively.
Similarly, business, management and marketing programs yielded 93,167 graduates over the same time frame. The University of Colorado Boulder and Colorado State University led in business-related degree completions, producing 15,644 and 15,449 graduates, respectively.
Yet, a Common Sense Institute study reveals that, despite rising state appropriations for higher education, Colorado’s funding formula does not actually prioritize those kinds of credentials that have economic value. They are degrees or certificates that offer students a clear return on investment — usually by leading to high-paying, high-demand jobs in sectors such as health care, computer science, engineering and skilled trades.
In other words, the state’s funding formula for higher education is disconnected from outcomes. New research from Common Sense Institute shows that Colorado’s performance-based higher education funding formula does not prioritize the performance it aims to achieve.
To be clear, higher education institutions’ funding comes from a myriad of sources, including tuition dollars. Common Sense Institute’s study chose to focus on the state’s funding formula — i.e., the portion of higher-ed funding consisting of our tax dollars. It is an important component.
Since the state adopted the formula in 2020, it has spent millions on performance bonuses — while producing fewer high-value credentials. This is an ongoing issue, not just a statistical fluke.
The data shows a steady decline in such credential production — and minimal impact from the formula’s incentives. Over 97% of higher education funding in Colorado is essentially locked in, based on prior allocations. The portion tied to performance — based on eight factors like graduation rate, first-generation enrollment, and retention — accounts for less than 3% of state funding.
Among the eight performance factors that 3%, only one — what academic credentials are produced — relates directly to educational output. The nonproduction metrics are more heavily weighted. Credential production is weighted at 5%, while Pell eligibility, first generation student status, and student retention are each weighted at 20%.
The Common Sense Institute does not argue the well-meaning intent behind these proxies for access and equity. They do not, however, say anything about the value of the degree, its alignment with labor market needs, or whether a graduate is equipped to succeed in Colorado’s economy.
Since 2020, Colorado institutions have received nearly $7 million in performance-based bonuses tied to credential production. During that same time, credential output dropped by more than 2,100. That’s an average cost of $1,058 per credential — up from $784 just a few years earlier.
The Common Sense Institute modeled what would happen if Colorado shifted its funding formula to emphasize these credentials of economic value, along with actual graduate earnings. In one scenario, a 50/50 weighting between credential value and employment outcomes would shift funding dramatically. For example:
· The University of Colorado system would gain $91 million
· Colorado School of Mines would gain $35 million
· The Community College System would gain $25 million
Meanwhile, institutions that generally produce less significant earnings for their graduates would see funding declines.
Smaller institutions would benefit in some cases. Many community colleges that offer short-term credentials in health care, IT and the trades perform well in Common Sense Institute’s analysis.
Aligning funding with credential value is one more building block for the state’s economy. Common Sense Institute projects that increasing the number of graduates with high-value credentials by just 20% would create nearly 19,000 jobs by 2035 and drive population growth of more than 24,000 — more than the capacity of Ball Arena.
These are not abstract projections. Colorado’s economy faces well-documented shortages in fields like skilled trades, health care support, computer sciences and information technology.
Many of these fields are underserved by Colorado’s higher ed institutions. Construction trades, for example, is one of the highest ROI credential areas for students. However, only 11 of the state’s 32 institutions even offer degrees in this field, producing fewer than 12,000 graduates over two decades. Only seven institutions offered legal studies programs between 2001 and 2021.
High-growth, high-value fields like business, health care, engineering, and computer science are producing solid numbers, but even those are still falling short of projected employer demand. The formula does little to correct that mismatch.
This matters. Colorado’s population is not booming as it once was. Its birth rate is low, and its population is aging. The state needs to maximize the number of able, trained workers in high-demand fields as homegrown supply is getting scarcer and new workers are moving here at slowing rates.
There are models Colorado could follow to right the ship. Some states have tied funding to student outcomes and workforce needs.
Florida rewards institutions based on the wages their graduates earn a year after graduation. Tennessee weights job placement and degree completion in high-need fields. Texas just revamped its community college funding formula to prioritize economically disadvantaged students and completion of high-value credentials.
Colorado uses a model that emphasizes “continuity” over responsiveness. That means an institution could make improvements in some of the performance metrics and still experience stable — or even increased — funding. In an age of budget shortages and slowing economic growth, how we fund higher education matters.
To make Colorado’s higher education system truly performance-based on the data, Common Sense Institute’s report includes a few considerations for policymakers.
1. Significantly increase the weight given to credential production — especially in fields with high ROI.
2. Introduce graduate earnings and employment outcomes as funding metrics. This will encourage institutions to track and improve workforce alignment.
3. Reduce funding lags and tie allocations to more current performance data. Three- and four-year lags remove accountability from the system.
4. Preserve base funding to protect essential programs, but ensure new appropriations reward impact, not inertia.
5. Encourage institutions to scale up high-demand programs through targeted incentives and streamlined program approvals.
These changes wouldn’t just serve the state — they’d serve students.
Colorado’s higher education funding formula is due for an update this year. This report is a resource to those policymakers carefully considering ways to modernize the formula. While this report is valuable to those decision-makers, students are the true customers of higher education and would benefit from the data, as well
Getting more information into their hands about which degrees are most in-demand and will lead to strong wages is critical. When more students earn credentials with economic value, the taxpayer wins and the entire Colorado economy benefits from added GDP, output, and personal income.
As Colorado policymakers examine ways to update how higher education is funded in Colorado, the data supports prioritizing more outcomes around credentials of economic value.
Colorado’s institutions would have a more significant incentive to ramp up the types of attainment awards offered and this kind of investment would have a rippling effect on graduates’ workforce readiness, economic mobility and quality of life.
This is something I think every Coloradan can get behind.
Caitlin McKennie, Ph.D., is director of policy and research for Colorado’s Common Sense Institute.







