Finger pushing


Perspective: Colorado vs. the First Amendment

The left in Colorado is assaulting the First Amendment, and all three branches of government are culprits.

Start with the governor-appointed Colorado Civil Rights Commission (CCRC). In a recent victory for free speech rights, website designer Lorie Smith of 303 Creative won a settlement from the CCRC to pay her $1.5 million in legal fees for defending her right to choose what messages her creative work will convey. The commission’s aggressive drive for government-mandated speech will cost taxpayers — not the commissioners — real dollars.

In 2018, the U.S. Supreme Court put CCRC in its place when it ruled that the commission had demonstrated extreme bias against Jack Phillips of Masterpiece Cakeshop because of his religious convictions. But the commission later countenanced additional cases against Phillips over his deeply held beliefs. There’s a pattern here.

The commission doesn’t simply want to create a level playing field for customers in the free market. In Orwellian fashion, it wants to force individuals and businesses to exercise their free speech only in ways that it approves. The federal 10th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that Colorado could indeed do this to Lorie Smith before being overruled by the U.S. Supreme Court.

Nobody argues that halal or kosher businesses should be forced to create products that violate their religious laws. It seems that the CCRC focuses primarily on forcing Christians to violate their consciences, based almost entirely on traditional Christian views on human sexuality. Clearly that might change as antisemitism thrives in our universities and institutions.

The latest move by the state Legislature was to expand the Colorado Anti-Discrimination Act last session so that “places of public accommodation” now include religiously-affiliated institutions — among them religious schools. It clarifies that the status, “Does not include a church, synagogue, mosque, or other place that is principally used for religious purposes.”

In other words, freedom of worship is fine, but free exercise is not. Worship inside the four walls of a building primarily used only for worship is permissible still.

But if a religious organization believes that its divine mandate includes charity or education, under the Colorado Anti-Discrimination Act it will not be allowed full expression and exercise of that religious mission. It might be forced to make programs and facilities available to those who are hostile to their beliefs — indeed requiring it to endorse speech and beliefs that it cannot in good faith.

There is a long history of cases dating back to at least 1988, where courts usually have declared that churches, religious schools, and religious programs are not places of public accommodation.

Justice Neil Gorsuch wrote in the 303 Creative decision that “no public accommodations law is immune from the demands of the Constitution . . . and when a state public accommodations law and the Constitution collide, there can be no question which must prevail.”

Ultimately, a public accommodations case may arise in Colorado to test the most recent expansion of the Colorado Anti-Discrimination Act. When that happens, it may well have to go to the United States Supreme Court for final determination.

Colorado government wants to compel other kinds of speech, too. Three years ago, the governor signed into law HB21-1321, forcing biased and misleading speech to be included in citizen ballot initiatives regarding tax cuts. The intent of the Secretary of State’s Office seems to be to manipulate Colorado voters by suggesting speculative negative consequences for other government programs, scaring citizens into voting to retain higher taxes. Advance Colorado is now asking the Supreme Court to grant review of their case Advance Colorado v. Griswold, hoping to set a precedent that prohibits government from manipulating voters right before an election.

In October, the Colorado Supreme Court decided another court case targeting Jack Phillips, dismissing the case in favor of Phillips on narrow procedural grounds while avoiding the constitutional question of free speech vs. anti-discrimination laws.

Attorneys with Alliance Defending Freedom had asked the state Supreme Court to affirm the 303 Creative decision affirming free speech rights, but it failed to do so. It’s uncertain whether the Colorado Supreme Court will affirm that precedent in the future. Their brief adventure into political primaries suggests they have a mind of their own about whether precedent applies to them.

The justices clearly do not side with free speech rights and some refuse to acknowledge even that all messages have meaning. Justice Richard Gabriel dissented, “I am concerned that Masterpiece and Phillips will construe today’s ruling as a vindication of their refusal to sell nonexpressive products with no intrinsic meaning to customers who are members of a protected class …”

Since at least 1886, when Coca Cola was launched, companies have branded and marketed their products to persuade customers that they are not merely buying something with no intrinsic meaning. The taste, the lifestyle, the image, the experience, the expression of the customer’s true person — many products tell you that their brand defines your identity.

Common sense would tell you that if Nike, Carhartt, and Coke are more than merely nonexpressive products, surely the individualized, specially designed products and messages of creative artists are perhaps the peak of expression and meaning. In fact, it’s impossible to deliver a message that has no meaning.

The governor, the Legislature, the Colorado Supreme Court, and the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals are burying their heads in the sand, trying hard to ignore the long train of U.S. Supreme Court precedent on freedom of speech and expression.

In the Hurley case, the Supreme Court ruled that veterans in Boston could not be forced to include an LGBTQ group in their parade as it was a type of protected speech. In Boy Scouts v. Dale, it ruled that the Boy Scouts could not be forced against their beliefs to employ a gay scoutmaster. In McCullen v. Coakley the court declared that government may not interfere with “an uninhibited marketplace of ideas.” Add in Tinker, Snyder v. Phelps, Whitney, Barnette, and others, and it is clear that the Supreme Court consistently rules in favor of free speech against government-compelled speech.

So perhaps Colorado’s government institutions are not avoiding the clear precedent — but desire to fundamentally remake free speech in the U.S. starting right here at home.

To make sure that desire does not become reality, several things need to happen to protect the First Amendment in Colorado.

1. Gov. Polis and the state Legislature should disband or fundamentally reform the Colorado Civil Rights Commission. Its heavy-handed approach and clear anti-religious bias are inconsistent with its intended mission. It is a national embarrassment.

2. The Legislature should update the Colorado Anti-Discrimination Act to exclude religious schools, charities, and nonprofits from the public accommodations rule. When a case arises to challenge the recently enacted, overly broad definition, the state will lose. Don’t wait for the courts to decide, change it now.

3. The Colorado State Supreme Court needs to return to being a neutral arbiter of truth. The liberal bias of all seven justices is frequently evidenced, as in its overturned decision to keep President-elect Trump off the ballot and its sidestepping the 303 Creative decision.

4. Our elected officials need to hear citizens’ voices raised in support of the First Amendment. Call and write to your representatives as well as the governor and demand they do more to protect free speech. Testify at legislative hearings. Talk to your friends and neighbors about it.

As Justice Neil Gorsuch has said, “The opportunity to think for ourselves and to express those thoughts freely is among our most cherished liberties and part of what keeps our republic strong.”

Tom Copeland, Ph.D., is the director of research at the Centennial Institute of Colorado Christian University. He writes regularly on public policy and the intersection of politics, culture and religion. The views expressed by the author are his own and do not represent the views of Centennial Institute or Colorado Christian University.

COURTESY OF Centennial Institute COURTESY OF Centennial Institute Tom Copeland, director of research for the Centennial Institute and professor of politics at Colorado Christian University. (COURTESY OF Centennial Institute)
COURTESY OF Centennial Institute COURTESY OF Centennial Institute Tom Copeland, director of research for the Centennial Institute and professor of politics at Colorado Christian University. (COURTESY OF Centennial Institute)
Baker Jack Phillips, owner of Masterpiece Cakeshop in Lakewood, manages his shop June 4, 2018, after the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that his refusal to make a wedding cake for a same-sex couple because of his religious beliefs did not violate Colorado’s antidiscrimination law. Now, Phillips is challenging a separate ruling that he violated the law by refusing to make a cake celebrating a gender transition. (the associated press file)
Baker Jack Phillips, owner of Masterpiece Cakeshop in Lakewood, manages his shop June 4, 2018, after the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that his refusal to make a wedding cake for a same-sex couple because of his religious beliefs did not violate Colorado’s antidiscrimination law. Now, Phillips is challenging a separate ruling that he violated the law by refusing to make a cake celebrating a gender transition. (the associated press file)
istock/getty images (istock/getty images)
istock/getty images (istock/getty images)
getty images (getty images)
getty images (getty images)
colorado flag (getty images)
colorado flag (getty images)
Tags columnists


Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests