Finger pushing


PERSPECTIVE: Voting for choice

The term school choice often means different things to different people and comes in several forms. But there are two clear ways by which Coloradans have benefited from school choice for more than 30 years.

One is a state law passed in 1994 providing parents the right to enroll their children in any public school in any district if space is available. This applies statewide, and the practice is best known as open enrollment.

The other parental right came a year earlier, in 1993, with the introduction of charter schools, which are semi-autonomous public schools that allow more specialization, experimentation and community engagement in the educational process. A charter school generally has more flexibility than traditional public schools regarding curriculum, fiscal management and overall school operations.

While the default is students being directed to nearby public schools based on their address, these school choice measures provide parents with options that lie outside the traditional school assignment model.

In November, voters will decide whether to pass Amendment 80, which would enshrine the full spectrum of school choice options into law. The state’s long history with charter schools provides reliable evidence that Colorado students have greatly benefited from this specific form of school choice. The number of families that send their students to charter schools in Colorado continues to grow.

Under Colorado law, public charter schools have no ability to exercise unfair selectivity in student admissions. With the same accountability standards as other public schools in Colorado, charter schools must meet state requirements regarding accreditation, adhere to content standards and graduation requirements, and participate in annual state testing for which results are made public.

Of the 45 states that have passed charter school legislation, Colorado has the second-highest percentage of students attending these public charter schools, at 15%, following only Arizona’s 20%.

Considering charter school enrollment is optional — requiring a parent to opt out of their district-assigned school and go through a registration process at the charter school — we know this is an in-demand form of school choice and its continued growth is an indicator of success. Between 2011-12 and 2022-23, the number of students enrolled in charter schools in Colorado has grown from 83,478 to 137,722, a 65% increase.

For example, Denver Public Schools is the largest school district in the state, serving over 93,000 students. By contrast, if Colorado’s collective charter schools were considered a school district, it would dwarf the Denver Public Schools student population with its over 135,000 students.

Authorizing new charter schools at the district level is the responsibility of the elected school board, and the launch of new charter schools relies on their respective votes. Although Denver authorizes the most charter schools at 56, its the small, rural school district of Byers 32J with the highest percentage of students enrolled in district-authorized charter schools — 91%. Twenty-two Colorado school districts have authorized three or more charter schools, demonstrating their popularity. Enrollment increased in 18 of those 22 districts between 2018-19 and 2022-23.

While some school choice critics worry that Amendment 80 potentially opens the door to other forms of choice, including tax credits, vouchers and Education Savings Accounts, any such change would require legislative action. And even though charter schools in Colorado have always enjoyed bipartisan support, the likelihood of this type of legislation succeeding seems doubtful under the current composition of the state Legislature.

A report I recently co-wrote for the Common Sense Institute — Better Choices, Better Outcomes: How Charter Schools Elevate Student Performance And Family Options — clearly illustrates how beneficial charter schools have been to the educational outcomes of a diverse group of students across Colorado. A few of the report’s findings in particular stand out, and make a compelling case for continuing to encourage the growth and expansion of the charter school sector.

First, the academic performance of charter school students — as measured by the state’s official assessment, Colorado Measures of Academic Success — was higher again in 2023-24 than those of noncharter school students at every grade level on English Language Arts and Math assessments in grades 3 through 8. This has generally been true in previous years as well. In fact, the Colorado Department of Education found that “a clear trend does show charter schools’ scores are almost always higher than noncharter schools.’

Second, a greater percentage of charter school students are students of color than are district-run public school students. This has been the case since the 2015-16 school year.

Given that students of color in the aggregate have lower test scores than white students, this suggests that students of color in charter schools are outperforming their peers in district schools. Also of note, since 2013, charters have educated more multilingual students than their district-run counterparts.

Third, graduates of charter high schools obtained a postsecondary credential — including bachelor or associate degree, or certificate — at a rate of 41.8%, compared with noncharters’ 32.8% for their 2016 graduation base. This is an important finding, because while a high school diploma is an essential credential to earn for future success, it alone is insufficient. It is hard to overstate the importance of acquiring a post-secondary credential.

Fourth, while chronic absenteeism has plagued schools since the COVID-19 pandemic shuttered schools in 2020, chronic absenteeism has been a widespread challenge for schools of all types. It is notable, however, that charters have significantly lower chronic absenteeism rates than district-run schools — 26.4% compared with 33%.

Despite absenteeism rates dropping from 2022 to 2023, a third of noncharter students were chronically absent in the most recent school year compared to just over a quarter of charter students. Schools looking to boost student outcomes will need to grapple with these elevated absenteeism rates.

It’s important to note that charter schools do not receive the state-funded transportation resources district schools do. This makes it more remarkable that charters maintain steady enrollment growth, notably less chronic absenteeism, and still significantly outperform district schools academically.

Colorado’s policymakers — legislators and the voting public — should boldly reward what works.

If Amendment 80 passes, it could be used as a tool to encourage more school districts to authorize charter schools. Colorado should continue to build on the number of rigorous, diverse, and family-friendly charter schools, as they are a value-add to the state’s educational ecosystem and should be expanded to accommodate growing demand from families.

Jason Gaulden is a Denver-based partner at Oak Rose Group, a strategy consulting firm specializing in education, workforce development and economic mobility. He also serves as education fellow at the Common Sense Institute. Gaulden holds a bachelor of arts degree in sociology from the University of Colorado Colorado Springs.

Colorado Fellows Website (300 x 400 px) - 9 (Common Sense Institute)
Colorado Fellows Website (300 x 400 px) – 9 (Common Sense Institute)
091324-dg-editorial-1 (Getty Images)
091324-dg-editorial-1 (Getty Images)
Tags columnists


Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests