Finger pushing


COLUMN: Is online technology regressing our intellect?

COLUMN: Recent boycotts are just virtue signaling

Is Google making us stupid? The answer might shock you.

Rachel Stovall
Rachel Stovall

In 2011, Nicholas Carr wrote a book asking this question — “The Shallows: What the Internet Is Doing to Our Brains.” Pikes Peak Library District sponsored an author visit to Colorado College where he shared his research with us locally. The Pulitzer Prize winning book was strangely prescient. Reprinted in 2020, it is even more relevant today.

You see, few people actually research topics. A survey done in January by Pew Research found that 83% of U.S. adults report using YouTube as an information source. According to this same survey, 68% report using Facebook and 47% report using Instagram in the same way.

None of these mediums require sources to be verified. Consequently, many of us have elevated unresearched opinions from entertainment sources — to the level of news.

Carr, a nonfiction researcher, views the internet as “not just technological progress but a form of human regress.” To regress is quite serious. In the midst of emotional/intellectual regression, we lose the ability to think critically or to respond to stress in a mature manner. Sounds like some people you’ve observed on YouTube, Facebook, and Instagram, doesn’t it?

If we dare, we’ll find that hyperinteraction on the internet hurts us. Especially on a cellphone. Nicholas Carr shares in The Wall Street article — “How Smartphones Hijack Our Minds”, “If you are like the typical owner, you’ll be pulling your phone out and using it some 80 times a day, according to data Apple collects. That means you’ll be consulting the glossy little rectangle 30,000 times over the coming year.”

Research from The Journal of the Association for Consumer Research tells us “… the integration of smartphones into daily life appears to cause a brain drain that can diminish such vital mental skills as learning, logical reasoning, abstract thought, problem solving and creativity.”

So, in addition to causing emotional regression, hyperregular internet usage is diminishing our ability to read, comprehend or even think beyond a shallow level.

This is even worse for children. According to a survey by Common Sense Media, the percentage of teenagers who feel addicted to their phones has increased from 39% in 2015 to 50% in 2021. That is just the teens who will admit to having an issue.

American Psychological Association report, released in April, states that school-aged kids do not have “the experience, judgment and self-control” to manage themselves on those platforms.” In the underdeveloped brains of children, a nonstop flood of information, messages, and images mirrors ADHD.

Overusage of a cellphone disrupts proper brain function and affects the ability to maintain focus on a single task for an extended period. This issue can also cause debilitating anxiety.

CNN summarizing social psychologist Jonathan Haidt’s book “The Anxious Generation: How the Great Rewiring of Childhood Is Causing an Epidemic of Mental Illness” warns us, “We’re at a tipping point as a society, and if grown-ups don’t take action, they could risk the mental health of all young people indefinitely.”

Pretty sobering news. Thankfully, schools are intervening.

In March, KOAA reported that private school St. Mary’s High School and charter Eastlake High School in Colorado Springs are separating students of all ages from their phones during the school day. Time Magazine also reported “Eastlake High School now is one of thousands of schools across the world that have turned to Yondr in order to combat phone addiction and distraction. Founded in 2014, Yondr has rapidly expanded since the pandemic and now serves more than one million students in twenty-one countries.”

School District 11 is implementing its own version of these measures. On the fact sheet for parents they said, “We would not be doing this if we felt student safety would be compromised. Cellphones can actually create a distraction for students that can compromise their safety, both in emergencies and day-to-day as it relates to bullying and violence.”

I am glad to see District 11 do something about the problem. Hopefully, many school districts will follow suit.

Destin Rodriguez from Eastlake High School in Colorado Springs told his story to KOAA.

“At first I was hesitant, giving up my phone, it’s a big thing, but after seeing the potential benefits of it, I’ve been more engaged in class, getting more work done,” said the young man.

He also said, “I’m interacting with more people than I used to.” Destin continues, “It can be beneficial for you to grow into that habit of putting your phone down and enjoying the world around you.”

Wise words. Only decreasing usage of your phone stops the effects of past over usage. Don’t let Google make you stupid.

Rachel Stovall is an event manager, entertainer and community advocate.

Tags columnists


Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests