Finger pushing


Perspective: Point/Counterpoint – State Legislative Wrap-Up

POINT: Lisa LaBriola

The curtains have closed on the 2024 legislative session, bringing forth profound changes for Coloradans. This session shines brightly in recent memory, as our Legislature courageously tackled complex and challenging policies while working toward bipartisan solutions.

Key policy issue

A key policy under intense scrutiny has been the state’s law on medical malpractice noneconomic damage caps, a contentious issue with threats of dueling proposals for voters to consider in November.

Since its inception in the late 1980s, this cap remained stagnant, prompting arguments from both sides.

While advocates for its removal emphasized the need for victims to receive adequate compensation in the face of increasing health care costs, opponents voiced concerns over the potential repercussions: increased health care expenses, soaring insurance premiums and potential loss of providers. In a bipartisan effort, the Legislature intervened, negotiating HB24-1472, a policy that gradually will increase the cap over the next five years.

Property taxes

Furthermore, the steep rise in property taxes has significantly affected Coloradoans’ finances. With the repeal of the Gallagher Amendment in November 2020, the Colorado General Assembly has been working to address this issue, convening a special session in November 2023 followed by a commission on property taxes. Faced with mounting pressure from an impending ballot initiative, a bipartisan group of members found a compromise and introduced SB24-233. This proposal promises relief to Coloradans by averting a tax hike this year and ensuring savings in the years to come.

Funding education

Education funding long has been a focal point in Colorado, especially in the aftermath of the Great Recession. Amid challenging budget deficits, lawmakers resorted to cuts from the constitutionally mandated education fund, which created the budget stabilization factor as a measure of the state’s funding shortfall. Despite unsuccessful past and present efforts from numerous legislators, a bipartisan coalition successfully eliminated this gap in this session through SB24-188.

As the nation’s political landscape continues its descent into ideological battlegrounds, we Coloradans can take pride in the work of our elected officials. Despite the disagreements and differing ideas on policy, our legislators were able to set aside their differences and prioritize we, the people, over party. I hope this continues to grow and becomes the norm and standard our legislature sets for future General Assemblies.

COUNTERPOINT: Sage NaumannHas the levee broken?

As I wrote last year, it was my opinion that the 2023 legislative session was a harbinger of things to come. We haven’t had an election since then, and as such, the makeup of the Legislature remains generally unchanged. Democratic leadership was able to once again stave off some of the most egregious pieces of legislation, but the walls continue to close in.

Affordable housing

On affordable housing, Democratic leadership still struggles with whether to expand or restrict supply. Legislation that permits accessory dwelling units statewide (HB24-1152), eliminates parking requirements (HB24-1304), and a ban on occupancy limits (HB24-1007) might expand housing options, but bills that give government the right of first refusal on affordable housing units (HB24-1175), expands regulations regarding the habitability of rental units (SB24-094), and restrictions on when a tenant can be evicted (HB24-1098) risk doing the opposite.

Two bills introduced to address construction defects (SB24-106, SB24-112) were scuttled earlier in the session — an issue I hope is revisited soon.

What’s next

As for what’s to come? We saw an ineffective and constitutionally questionable assault weapons ban (HB24-1292) make it further than it ever has before, safe injection sites fail by just a single vote in committee (HB24-1028), and legislation that attempts to dismantle decades of progress on charter schools be introduced (HB24-1363).

Unfortunately, these bills are indicative of the direction the Democratic Party is heading. Both sides of the aisle are losing a number of legislators that have been essential to maintaining rational debate in both chambers. This year’s primary election — and general election — will be extremely consequential in determining just how far to the left Colorado’s state government goes.

Bipartisan efforts

And before you consider me unwilling to give credit for bipartisanship, I agree with my counterpoint on two bills that she mentioned:

HB24-1448 will modify Colorado’s per-pupil funding formula, the first substantial change in three decades. Speaker McCluskie, Senate Minority Leader Lundeen, and others deserve credit for not letting another session pass without a solution. The status quo left students in Pueblo receiving much less per-pupil ($11,500) than students in more well-off districts such as Aspen ($18,600). Finally, we move toward prioritizing students over systems with our funding.

On the matter of property taxes, the last-minute “fix” that came in the final moments of the session (SB24-233) won’t actually cut property taxes as they currently stand, but it does slow the rate of increases in the future. While that falls short of what many are asking for, Sens. Kirkmeyer, Hansen, and others deserve credit for the bipartisan effort. At least, should any measure fail in November, future increases won’t be as painful.

For now, the levee stands, but it has never been weaker.

Lisa LaBriola is a principal at Husch Blackwell Strategies and was a Senate Democrat staffer for close to a decade. She served as chief of staff to former Senate Minority Leader Lucia Guzman and former Senate President Leroy Garcia. Opinions expressed here are her own and do not reflect the opinions of any other organizations. Sage Naumann is a conservative commentator and strategist. He is vice president of communications at 76 Group and was previously the spokesman for the Colorado Senate Republicans. Follow him on Twitter @SageNaumann.

LisaLabriola
LisaLabriola
Sage Naumann
Sage Naumann
Tags columnists


Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests