PERSPECTIVE: Nurses, too, must do no harm
Two decades ago, our family faced an experience that would forever shape my perspective on life, choices, and the importance of time in making profound decisions. It was a sunny day in June when a routine drive turned into a life-altering event. A car accident, unexpected and unforgiving, took the life of my sister and nearly claimed the life of my mother as well. The severity of her injuries prompted doctors to advise our family to consider the unthinkable, allowing her to die immediately.
The medical team painted a grim picture, emphasizing the extent of her injuries and suggesting that even if she survived, she likely would never regain full functionality or cognition. The weight of the decision ahead seemed insurmountable. The idea of ending a beloved life based on the potential for suffering was an ethical crossroad we never imagined we would navigate.
Our family, bound by love and an unwavering belief in the sanctity of life, chose a different path. We collaborated closely with the health care team, opting for supportive care instead of succumbing to the pressure to make a quick decision to end my mother’s life. We clung to hope, knowing that deciding to let her live meant embracing an uncertain journey of recovery.
The waiting period during those initial critical days allowed us time — time to absorb the shock, time to grasp the enormity of the situation, and most importantly, time to make decisions. It was a period filled with consultations, discussions and difficult conversations with the health care team. Together, we charted a course of supportive care, focusing on addressing my mother’s immediate needs while providing her with the best chance for a meaningful recovery.
The subsequent years unfolded as a testament to the power of time and the resilience of the human spirit. Against the odds, my mother not only survived but thrived. Two decades later, she stands as an independent and fully functioning adult. She pursued a career, built a family, and now revels in the joy of being a grandmother to eight grandchildren.
Reflecting on this experience, I cannot help but draw parallels to the potential consequences of the changes proposed by the Legislature to expand physician-assisted death. In our case, time was a crucial factor in making informed decisions that preserved life and allowed for unexpected recovery.
As a nursing professional and a family member who experienced a life-altering event, I am opposed to the newly introduced “Medical Aid-in-Dying” bill in the Colorado Senate, SB24-0068, expanding physician-assisted suicide.
Having dedicated my career to the care and well-being of patients, I believe that the proposed changes to Colorado law in the bill pose serious ethical and practical concerns that warrant reconsideration.
The sanctity of life is a fundamental tenet that underscores the inherent value and dignity of every individual. The Bible teaches us that human life is sacred and that only God has the authority to give and take life. The Psalmist writes that God forms everyone in the womb and knows them intimately. Many Bible passages emphasize the importance of cherishing life and providing compassionate care for those who are suffering. The act of intentionally accelerating death goes against the divine order and challenges the reverence for life that is fundamental in many religious systems. The Christian perspective, in alignment with the foundational principles of nursing, advocates for a commitment to alleviating pain and offering solace through palliative care rather than embracing actions that expedite the end of life.
One of the key principles of nursing is the commitment to promoting and preserving the well-being of individuals under our care. Central to this commitment is the principle of nonmaleficence, which emphasizes the obligation to “do no harm.” The act of hastening death through provider-assisted
suicide stands in direct conflict with this foundational principle. Nurses are advocates for life, and our primary goal is to alleviate suffering while upholding the dignity of each patient.
One major problem with SB24-0068 is granting advanced practice registered nurses (APRNs) — which includes nurse practitioners (NPs) — the same authority as physicians to prescribe life-ending drugs. While I respect the expertise and capabilities of APRNs and NPs, the act of prescribing such medications carries profound implications for patient care. The delicate decisions involved in end-of-life choices demand the comprehensive knowledge and experience possessed by physicians. Expanding this authority to APRNs risks undermining the necessary oversight and expertise required for such critical decisions and raises concerns about the scope of practice and the potential strain on the nurse-patient relationship.
For now, Colorado law prohibits employers and insurance policies from requiring that doctors and nurses participate in provider-assisted suicide. Voters should be concerned that it is a small procedural move but an enormous ethical leap to move from authorizing to requiring medical professionals to participate in PAS, a direct challenge to the professional and moral values of nearly all who practice medicine.
In addition, the bill advocates for the removal of the Colorado residency requirement for individuals seeking end-of-life options. Residency requirements ensure that individuals contemplating such significant decisions remain intricately connected to their own community and doctors. Eliminating this requirement exposes vulnerable individuals from out of
state to potential risks, as the lack of a longstanding connection may hinder thorough assessments and understanding of the patient’s background and available support system.
Reducing the waiting period from 15 days to 48 hours and allowing attending providers to waive the waiting period if a patient is unlikely to survive more than 48 hours raise ethical concerns regarding the potential for coercion and the expedited nature of such decisions. Safeguards in place to protect at-risk individuals from undue pressure and hasty decisions should not be compromised for the sake of convenience.
Decreasing the waiting period could limit the opportunity for families to fully explore alternatives, depriving individuals of the chance for unforeseen improvements and defying the predictions of medical professionals. My mother’s story has etched in my heart a deep appreciation for the value of time, thoughtful decision-making, and the profound impact of choices on the course of a life. It highlights the importance of upholding the sanctity of life and embracing the uncertainties that time can unfold.
Nursing is grounded in the values of compassion, empathy and holistic care. The medical profession emphasizes the provision of comfort and support to patients and their families throughout the entire health care journey,
including the end-of-life process. The nursing Code of Ethics highlights the importance of maintaining patient autonomy while also considering the broader ethical principles of beneficence and justice. These principles emphasize the responsibility of nurses to promote the well-being of patients and to advocate for actions that are ethically sound. Physician-assisted suicide introduces complex ethical dilemmas and compromises the well-being of vulnerable individuals, the broader community, and the holistic approach to care that nurses are trained to provide.
All nurses — including APRNs and NPs — are trained to prioritize open communication and collaboration with interdisciplinary healthcare teams. In the context of end-of-life care, this collaboration often involves discussions about palliative and hospice care options. This bill would hinder these collaborative efforts, as it introduces a paradigm shift that diverges from the comprehensive and compassionate approach to end-of-life care that nurses strive to provide.
The nurse’s role in my mother’s situation extended beyond clinical duties. They took the time to understand our family dynamics, our values, and our hopes for my mother’s recovery. This personal connection fostered an environment where we felt heard and valued as active participants in the decision-making process. The nurse’s empathetic approach helped alleviate the fear and uncertainty that shrouded those early days, allowing us to focus on supporting my mother through her journey.
In retrospect, the nurse-patient relationship in my story exemplifies the essence of collaborative and patient-centered care. The nurse served not only as a medical professional but as a compassionate advocate for our family. Their ability to navigate the delicate balance between providing clinical expertise and emotional support is essential in
this relationship in times of crisis.
In conclusion, as a nurse committed to upholding the highest standards of patient care and as a child of someone who defied a grim medical prognosis, I draw on ethical principles and a biblical perspective to strongly oppose SB24-0068.
The proposed changes not only have far-reaching consequences for individuals facing end-of-life decisions, but it also interferes with the core values of nursing, including the principles of nonmaleficence, holistic care, ethical advocacy, and collaboration. Nurses play a crucial role in promoting the well-being and dignity of individuals, and hastening death through assisted suicide undermines the very essence of our profession.
Kathryn Palermo, RN, DNP, is a faculty fellow with the Centennial Institute of Colorado Christian University. She holds a degree in practical theology, a BS in biology, a BS in nursing, a master’s degree in nursing leadership and management, and a doctorate of nursing practice. She has practiced in health care for 15 years and is a certified med-surg registered nurse. The majority of her nursing career was spent at the bedside in the acute care setting. The views expressed are those of the author and do not represent the views of Colorado Christian University or the Centennial Institute.






