Finger pushing


EDITORIAL: Don’t dumb down the 9th grade

For all the challenges facing American public education, Colorado commendably has made some significant strides toward reform. Our state has been a leader in expanding innovative educational options such as charter schools and online learning. We also have raised the bar on accountability for schools and educators, enacting watershed legislation in 2010 that based teachers’ performance evaluations, and ultimately tenure, in part on student test scores.

Unfortunately, a bill introduced in the new legislative session would roll back our hard-won progress on accountability, undermining our schools’ ability to gauge teacher performance. Senate Bill 5, co-sponsored by Sen. Michael Merrifield, D-Colorado Springs, would eliminate testing across the board for Colorado ninth-graders.

Merrifield is a longtime foe of education reforms and a reliable legislative ally of the accountability-averse teachers unions. That he would carry this bill comes as no surprise; it would reinforce a touchstone priority of the unions — bulletproof teacher tenure — even if it comes at the expense of student achievement.

What is more surprising, and troubling, is that the legislative sponsors of this ill-conceived measure also include some Republicans — whose party, ironically, long has championed these very same reforms. It is possible the Republicans aboard SB 5 see it as another platform for enunciating broader concerns about sweeping federal education mandates like the much-debated Common Core standards. However, they must take care not to confuse wheat with chaff.

Colorado’s groundbreaking accountability standards are not about imposing a dubious dictum on school curriculum; they are about measuring how well our schools are doing the job. As such, the state’s accountability reforms represent an effort to make public education more answerable to parents and taxpayers. Accountability is, fundamentally, a conservative value. As former President Ronald Reagan always said, “trust, but verify.”

It is also important to note that Colorado has reined in testing. In response to some parents’ concerns about excessive time spent on student assessment, compromise legislation enacted last year included cuts in standardized tests for grades and subjects where the changes would not compromise accountability. We supported that reasonable effort.

SB 5’s elimination of testing for ninth-graders, by contrast, essentially would leave our state with no meaningful, systematic way of measuring the efficacy of fully one-quarter of high school teachers. As we noted at the conclusion of last year’s legislative session in opposing an unsuccessful attempt at that time to cut ninth-grade testing, such proposals place the interests of teachers unions ahead of results in the classroom.

We strongly urge Colorado Springs Republican Sen. Owen Hill to lead the fight against this misguided measure when it debuts in the Senate education committee, which he chairs. While experience tells us there is little hope Merrifield will relent on this legislation, we hope his newfound Republican allies will reconsider their perhaps well-intended but misguided support for SB 5. Our children deserve better.

The Gazette

Tags opinion views


Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests