Finger pushing


EDITORIAL: Don’t question state CEO’s big raise

Just behave, state treasurer Walker Stapleton. Go along with the established governing class. Don’t ask questions. Toe the line and allow politicians to help fellow politicians. To do otherwise — to work as a defender of public funds — is just plain “asinine” and “stupid.”

That’s the message made clear last week by Lynn Turner, one of three governor-appointed members of the board of directors of Colorado’s Public Employees’ Retirement Association.

Stapleton has shown a commitment to defending the public interest against questionable agendas of the governing class. He was a front-line warrior against the proposal for a $1 billion tax increase, deceptively promoted as revenue for classrooms and teachers. Voters trounced the proposal in 2013, trusting Stapleton’s judgment. A member of the PERA board, Stapleton has pushed for transparency against the wishes of fellow board members and the pension’s ranking employees.

Stapleton’s commitment to serving the public rose to the level of “asinine” last week when he dared question an enormous raise for PERA Executive Director Gregory Smith.

It was apparently supposed to be a rubber stamp affair, with the board quickly approving a $1.8 million contract extension for Smith. The deal would include a $394,000 base salary for 2016, with possible 30 percent annual bonuses and a $200,000 retention bonus.

Stapleton, as reported in a Gazette news story, suggested the director’s bonuses should reflect performance and results. He recommended tying bonuses to factors such as the fund’s return on investment or reductions in the $26 billion unfunded liability. Doing so would benefit state employees and all other taxpayers of Colorado, who are ultimately at risk if the pension goes bust.

Stapleton’s suggestion was “stupid” and “asinine,” in the opinion of Turner.

“I’ve never heard anyone propose such a stupid idea,” Turner said.

We have heard considerably stupider ideas, most notably one that says a 30 percent bonus — about $120,000 a year — should have no basis in performance. In the world of wage earners, such as the Colorado’s teachers who work to fund PERA, bonuses are tied to performance. If Turner thinks Smith is somehow entitled to lower expectations than people who teach kids for $40,000 a year, then Turner should resign from the board.

In Turner’s world, Smith should get a giant raise even if his actions reduce the performance of investment funds generated by teachers and other government wage earners.

Smith isn’t exactly making a sacrifice by managing PERA. As Stapleton pointed out, the CEO of California’s much larger $300 billion retirement system receives a salary, combined with bonuses, of about $500,000. Smith, who manages a much smaller pension than California’s, will receive about $750,000 in salary and bonuses.

Smith’s defenders on the board told Stapleton the CEO deserves more than California’s because Smith manages more investments in-house. They approved his generous raise by a 12-1 vote.

If Smith deserves so much more because he makes investments, it is all the more reason to tie his bonuses to his decisions. Treat him like he lives among those state employees and taxpayers who fund the pension. Reward him as government critics frequently insist the private sector reward corporate CEOs.

Turner’s asinine comment highlights what is wrong with PERA. The majority of those who run it prefer immunity from accountability. They prefer to live in a world of illogical money management that is not scrutinized for results.

The Gazette

PERA board member Lynn Turner doesn't want the state treasurer to question the pension CEO's big new raise.
PERA board member Lynn Turner doesn’t want the state treasurer to question the pension CEO’s big new raise.


Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests