Finger pushing


TOWN HALL: Peyton Manning, go somewhere else (poll)

Peyton Manning, go to Houston, Phoenix or Miami. Just don’t come to Denver. Do not jump into one of the more bizarre quarterback controversies in the history of the NFL. You deserve a welcome reception and will not get one here

Manning, recovering from a neck injury and multiple surgeries near the end of his career, is shopping for a job after 14 seasons with the Indianapolis Colts. The super athlete’s next move has captured the attention of Americans. President Barack Obama weighed in on Monday, saying Denver will be chosen if Manning cares about scenery.

Denver would be a stupid move for Manning, and Manning would be a stupid acquisition for Denver. The fact that Broncos coach John Fox and Vice President John Elway courted him last week is downright embarrassing.

Manning, who turns 36 this month, epitomizes risk. Denver’s offensive line is a sieve. The pocket disintegrates in a blink. Manning will get sacked until he cannot stand.

Denver cannot court Manning, much less hire him, without snubbing Tebow — a great young athlete who will almost certainly leave. If Manning performs like an injured 36-year-old, fans will boo him and chant “Tebow” each time a pass goes awry. An American icon could spend his last few seasons in a city that resents him.

Manning won’t suffer alone. Fans will blame legendary Elway if the Broncos tank under Manning. “Tank” is a relative term in this equation. Run Tebow off and you had better win big. Anything less than a Super Bowl win next year will be viewed as failure.

Even if Manning somehow performs to high expectations, thousands of Coloradans will blame him for the loss of Tebow — a man who is beloved for his philanthropy toward disabled children as much as for football.

Tebow has an entire career ahead of him. He came off the bench last season to win six of the next eight games, after the Broncos had lost four of their first five. He put the Broncos on top of their division and got them into the playoffs for the first time in seven years. Then he did something no quarterback had accomplished for Denver since 2006. He won a playoff game. He won it with a pass.

Should the Denver Broncos hire Peyton Manning as quarterback? Vote in poll to the right. Must vote to see results.

Football purists don’t like Tebow’s style and claim that his stats undermine his wins. His quarterback ranking last season, his first season to start in the NFL, was 72.9. That’s not good, but it’s better than Manning’s rookie rating of 71.2. Quarterbacks look bad at first. Then they improve. That makes Tebow a promising investment.

Tebow fans, most notably Denver attorney and radio host Dan Caplis, use data to argue that Tebow is off to a better start than Elway, Manning and most of the greats. Tebow foes have their own data to support their opposition.

This much we know as fact: Tebow, in his first season as a starter, turned a losing team into a winning team. He became among the biggest celebrities in the country. He made football fans of people who never cared about the game. He is an enormous asset to Colorado. Broncos management will run him off at their own peril.

That’s our view. What’s yours? Please initiate or join in a Facebook discussion below, and vote in poll to the upper right.

Friend editorial page editor Wayne Laugesen on Facebook, follow him on Twitter

Must-see-daily site: Complete Colorado

Photo by
Photo by


Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests