Finger pushing


OUR VIEW: The might(y) vs the right factor

The latest GOP primaries didn’t decide much or establish a clear front-runner with Super Tuesday looming.

On one hand, Mitt Romney’s narrow win Tuesday in Michigan’s Republican presidential primary could be considered ho-hum. After all, Romney beat John McCain there in 2008, he grew up there, and his father was governor.

(Vote in poll at right)

On the other hand, Romney undeniably sweated out a hard-fought campaign that wasn’t decided for certain until all the votes were counted.

He acknowledged as much in his victory statement: “(We) didn’t win by a lot, but we won by enough, and that’s all that counts.” That doesn’t quite rise to the celebratory level of a victory lap. Romney also vowed to “cut, cap and balance” the budget, repeal ObamaCare, restore the country’s triple A credit rating, and “get us that oil from Canada that we deserve.”

Next up is Super Tuesday, with little time for the Romney campaign to apply its superior organizational and financial advantages in 10 states, many of which appear to lean to Rick Santorum’s social conservatism.

What can we glean from last week’s voting? One aspect worth examining is what we might call the “Right vs. Might(y)” factor.

First, the Right: Santorum won, 58 percent to 16 percent, among Michigan voters who said they preferred a “true conservative” and by 59 percent to 17 percent among voters who feel a candidate should have a strong moral character.

Now, the Might(y): Romney won, 61 percent to 24 percent, among voters who want a candidate they believe can beat President Barack Obama in November.

Was Tuesday’s balloting predictive or did it further muddy the picture?

The Right versus Might(y) aspect reveals a substantial and persistent divergence among Republicans. Being “right,” as in correct, and being on the “right,” as in conservative, apparently are qualities that, for some voters, supersede even the ability to win, as in “might.” And the converse can be said for those Republicans who elevate electability.

Certainly, both views have downsides. How much solace is there in being “right” if you lose and end up powerless? On the other hand, how much satisfaction is there in being mighty enough to win if you end up looking like what you defeated?

It’s also worth noting that, while Romney may have won Michigan four years ago, the man he defeated in that primary, John McCain, went on to win the party’s 2008 nomination. It wasn’t really close.

It’s also worth noting that if trends portend future events, Michiganders who voted early preferred Romney, but as ballots were cast closer to Election Day, voters preferred Santorum.

Was Michigan’s win a skin-of-the-teeth victory for Romney? Did he, as CNN put it, “survive Michigan” as opposed to emerge victorious? Or, as the Los Angeles Times put it, was this a case of “Mitt Romney averts disaster in Michigan primary”?

On the other hand, Romney crushed all the competition Tuesday in Arizona, including runner-up Santorum, whom Romney beat by 20 points.

Last Tuesday probably settled little, and Republicans still have much to decide. The GOP’s final four face the busiest primary day of 2012 next week on Super Tuesday, when voters hopefully will make a muddy picture a little clearer. — Freedom Communications

Tags our view


Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests