Finger pushing


How about trying science rather than trying science?

Why is it that whenever scientists make a distressing discovery about our world, we want to drag them before a trial or hearing to make them account for their findings, as The Gazette suggested in a September Our View? Historically, we know that trials have not fared well for getting at scientific truth. There are just too many issues at play in the civic sphere to allow real scientific understanding to prevail — consider for instance Lysenko’s purge of Soviet scientists or the Scopes trial here in the U.S. Imagine trying to decide as a citizen if quantum theory was true or not. Personally, I’d vote against that kind of weirdness in my world, wouldn’t you?

The trial of Galileo is particularly instructive on this point because it is not only a cautionary tale about authority’s corrosive interference in scientific debates, but its resolution also gives us insights into how science does work. Galileo was a champion of the Copernican model of the universe, which holds that the Earth and all the planets orbited about the sun. Copernicus’ theory of heliocentrism contradicts numerous elements of scripture, which set the earth at the center of the universe, and so Galileo ran afoul of church authority.

As a result of his writings, Galileo was found guilty of heresy by the Inquisition — which I’m sure he was — and ultimately ordered imprisoned to house arrest. As part of his sentence, Galileo was ordered to recant heliocentrism.

Of course, we realize today that Copernicus and Galileo were right, the earth does orbit around the sun and not vise-versa, but what is generally forgotten is that the Copernican theory was wrong on one important point, and that in the early 1600s there were legitimate reasons to question it. As one functionary of the church pointed out, the Copernican theory did not quite fit the data. In fact, for the exact position of planets, the Copernican theory fit no better than existing models that placed the Earth at the center of the universe. The problem was that Copernicus made an incorrect assumption about the shape of planetary orbits; he believed they followed the “perfect” shape of a circle. It was not until Kepler showed that planets moved in elliptical orbits that heliocentrism was shown to account better for the available data.

But the problems for heliocentrism don’t stop there. In order to explain the apparent motion of the moon, planets, sun and stars across the sky, heliocentrism also relies on the idea that the Earth rotates on its axis. The basic problem is this: If the earth is spinning at nearly 800 mph at the middle latitudes, why does a cannon ball shot straight up in the air come down in approximately the same spot and not thousands of yards to the west? To understand why this is the case, you have to understand Newton’s laws of motion. Thus, it was only after Newton published his work — more than 50 years after Galileo’s trial — that all the problems of heliocentrism were solved and it became a widely accepted theory.

The trial of Galileo by the church did not get at the truth. One could argue that its judgment may have inhibited scientific debate on the issue. Scientific understanding only increases through an open debate among those devoted to understanding our natural world. In the civic realm, all kinds of other considerations come into play — faith, power, wealth, glory, etc. In scientific debate, the main objective is to understand our world. This concern trumps all others.

Instead of trying scientific theories in public hearings or on the editorial pages in our newspapers, we should let science do what it does best, come to an ever-widening understanding of our world. Then, we would be wise to shape our public policies as best we can within that understanding. Putting science on trial has never worked; trying science — as a way of understanding our world — does.

—

Horner is a professor of psychology at Colorado College.

Rapper DMX Photo by Associated Press



Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests