Finger pushing


Think before challenging Founders

Barack Obama is president of the United States of America.

I made that declaration to a good friend of mine the other day. She waited for its sequel and, when she realized it wasn’t forthcoming, cocked a quizzical eyebrow.

Sometimes commonplace expressions warrant the most rigorous analysis. Any phrase with the longevity of “president of the United States of America” contains depths rendered increasingly obscure by the passage of time.

Barack Obama is president of the United States of America, not the People’s Republic of America.

I’m repeating that fact because the Colorado House of Representatives just passed a bill, sponsored by Rep. Andy Kerr, D-Loveland, that would require Colorado’s members of the Electoral College to cast their ballots for whichever candidate won the popular vote nationwide, even if Coloradans overwhelmingly preferred his opponent. It would go into effect once enough states passed similar legislation.

No single state could actually abolish the Electoral College, an institution established by the Constitution of the United States of America. Kerr just wants to render the Electoral College meaningless. His bill would go a long way toward shattering, with one presumptuous stroke, the intricate machinery which balances the interests of small states against the interests of large states, and then balances that balance against the interests of the country as a whole.

We might as well give the president of the United States of America a new title, because he would cease to represent the states.

It’s true that this bill wouldn’t completely destroy our ingenious American system. The Senate would continue to represent the states, and the House of Representatives would continue to represent the people. But like the Congress, the presidency is also designed to represent the interests of both the states individually and America as a whole.

The Electoral College ensures that relatively small states, such as Colorado, aren’t ignored when it comes to presidential campaigns and executive policy. The number of electors from any given state is calculated by taking its number of congressmen (whose representation is based on population) and adding its number of senators (two for every state, large and small).

Just as a state’s two U.S. senators ensure that every state, no matter how insignificant its population, possesses a considerable voice in the halls of Congress, its two corresponding electors ensure that every state possesses a considerable voice in the Oval Office.

The Democrats base their argument for destroying this beautiful arrangement on the premise that Kerr’s bill would give new weight to the votes of Republicans in states such as New York, which usually bind all their electors to the Democratic candidate, and to the votes of Democrats in states such as Alaska, which usually bind all their electors to the Republican candidate.

But Rep. Bob Gardner, R-Colorado Springs, observes that individual states can allocate their electors however they please. While most choose to give all their electors to whichever candidate wins the state’s popular vote, Maine and Nebraska allot them based upon the votes in each congressional district. “If the Democrats are concerned that ‘every vote should count,’ then they should encourage states to award their electoral votes on a proportional basis. But, of course, Colorado’s voters overwhelmingly rejected a ballot initiative that would have done that in 2004.”

As for me, I’d be happy if our Democratic legislators worried more about representing Coloradans and less about “enfranchising” Democrats in Alaska.

There’s no question that our federalist system is complex. That reality hit home when I was living in Rome a couple years ago. I simply couldn’t get my Italian landlady to understand the nature of the relationship between America’s federal government and her semi-autonomous states, with their distinct cultures, traditions and bodies of law.

Federalism was a completely alien concept to her.

It’s a concept alien to modern Americans as well. We forget that we’re not only Americans, but Coloradans, with a heritage all our own.

But no matter what we tend to forget nowadays, we should always resist impulses to undermine institutions which have served the United States with honor and distinction for more than 200 years.

The conservative mind has a healthy prejudice in favor of things that are old, tested and established. That doesn’t mean that we don’t find things to improve. It simply means that, when we think we might disagree with the Founding Fathers, we think long and hard before proclaiming our wisdom superior to theirs.

–

Cole, of Colorado Springs, is a writer, translator and political organizer. Readers can reach him at dancoloradan@yahoo.com.

 

Parade of “horseless carriages” through downtown Colorado Springs passes past crowds in front of the First National Bank Building. The Antlers Hotel is visible in background. Photo by Pikes Peak Library District Special Collections



Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests