Security at the welcome mat
The Rev. Brady Boyd was having lunch with a friend in his office at New Life Church when he heard something that reminded him of his childhood in rural Louisiana: gunshots.
Having grown up hunting game in the Louisiana woods, Boyd was familiar with the popping sound of gunfire, but the echoing barrage he heard on the New Life campus on Dec. 9, 2007, was beyond comprehension – something he never expected at a place of worship.
“Hearing gunshots being fired at people you love is something you never forget,” Boyd said.
The shooting took the lives of teenage sisters Rachel and Stephanie Works, wounded their father, David, and left the congregation shaken to its core.
But that day of violence had implications beyond the Briargate-area church, raising the question of how far worship centers should go to protect themselves. In a place ostensibly meant to convey serenity and good will, are gun-toting security guards too extreme?
Boyd believes every worship center needs a security plan and has said that high-profile churches should consider having armed guards. It was, after all, an armed volunteer security guard at New Life who helped bring down the shooter, Matthew Murray.
But not every religious leader is ready to commit to armed guards, or even security measures in general. John Casey wonders why.
Casey, who was New Life’s director of security when the shooting occurred and gives lectures across the U.S. on church security, notes that malls, schools and other public gathering places have increased security over the years. Churches, however, have failed to follow suit. Of the 500 churches in El Paso County, only about 10 percent have a formal security team, Casey said.
“I don’t think a lot of faith leaders have put much thought into security,” Casey said.Even if they’ve thought about it, though, some religious leaders aren’t interested in pursuing it.
“We don’t have no need for it right now,” said John Fuller, pastor of Harbor Lights, a nondenominational church in Colorado Springs with about 50 parishioners.
The Rev. Dave Shumpert of the Cowboy Church of Peyton, which has a weekly attendance of 125, said his church doesn’t have the funds or see the need to hire a guard or implement security procedures during services.
“If someone is going to do something, they will do it,” Shumpert said. “You can’t pat down every person who comes here to worship. That is not how you welcome people to your church.”
John Nicoletti, a police psychologist in Lakewood who speaks nationally on church and school security, said having no security plan is naive. Although church shootings are rare, they appear to be on the increase since the New Life shooting, in the same way that a spike in school shootings followed the Columbine tragedy, Nicoletti said.
In July, an unemployed gunman killed two people and wounded eight during a service at a Unitarian-Universalist church in Knoxville, Tenn. And two weeks ago, on Nov. 23, a gunman showed up during a Sunday service at an Orthodox church in New Jersey and killed his wife and a church director. That same day, a security guard at the Church of Scientology’s Celebrity Centre in Hollywood killed a man on campus brandishing swords in a threatening manner.
“Once something like this happens, you can never go back to the way it used to be,” Nicoletti said.
Creating a plan for churches
Casey and Nicoletti are two of only a handful of law-enforcement professionals holding seminars nationwide on church security.
Casey, who resigned his position at New Life this year to head the National Association of Church and School Security in Colorado Springs, instructs faith leaders on how to create strategic plans to thwart a violent intruder and save lives. Security personnel also need to be trained in basic medical care and how to spot potentially aggressive people and diffuse them before they act, he said.
As for having armed guards at churches, Casey leaves that decision up to each church.
“Should we carry guns in church? I cannot answer that,” Casey said. “But if you cannot meet or exceed the level of violence, you will have to succumb to the will of that person.”
While head of New Life security -and before the 2007 shooting- Casey had implemented a layered approach to church security: uniformed and armed police officers, and armed and unarmed undercover security, all in contact with one another through ear pieces.Nicoletti and other security experts praised New Life’s system, pointing to the scores of lives saved when, after mortally wounding the Works sisters, Matthew Murray entered the northeast hallway of New Life with guns blazing. Minutes later he was dead, having taken his life after being shot multiple times by volunteer security guard Jeanne Assam.
Since the shootings, New Life has bolstered its security from three to six uniformed police officers and has added several more undercover guards. New Life has 15 to 20 security personnel on any given Sunday.
“We live in an environment where violence happens in public places,” Boyd said. “Just like every mall or shopping center or hospital should have some type of security plan, so should churches.”
Some have security plan
Despite the low percentage of churches still without a formal security plan, a few local worship centers have gotten the message.
Mountain Springs Church, with a congregation of about 2,800, had no security program one year ago. Today, the church has an off-duty armed sheriff’s deputy on duty Sunday morning and has created a volunteer security team that includes some armed undercover personnel.
“Churches that aren’t putting in place a security procedure are not being honest with themselves,” said Rich Hobbs, director of life safety at Mountain Springs. “No place is truly a safe haven anymore.”
The New Life shooting prompted First Presbyterian Church downtown to beef up its security. Before, the 5,000-member church had four uniformed police officers as well as undercover officers and volunteer security personnel during Sunday services, said Warren Gerig, head of the church’s Life and Safety Ministry. The church recently added a lock-down strategy, practiced fire drills and arranged to have a Colorado Springs police SWAT team rehearse procedures on campus, Gerig said.
Smaller churches have also begun security programs.
Forestgate Presbyterian, which averages 200 worshippers a week, has 12 undercover personnel, some of whom are armed, patrolling during Sunday worship, said Forestgate security head R.Y. Costain. Guards have been trained to identify suspicious-looking people and take specific actions in the case of medical emergencies and bomb threats.
“The New Life shooting made it loud and clear that these things do happen at churches,” Costain said.
“It is a new day.”
–
CONTACT THE WRITER: 636-0367 or mark.barna@gazette.com.DETAILSWhat: Memorial service for Rachel and Stephanie WorksWhere: New Life Church, 11025 Voyager Parkway, near northeast entranceWhen: 1 p.m. Tuesday
Air Force players and fans celebrate Josh Frider’s third period goal against Rochester Institute of Technology at the Cadet Ice Arena Friday, Dec. 5, 2008, giving Air Force a 2-0 lead. Photo by KEVIN KRECK, THE GAZETTE





