Our illegal homeless
For Stanley Smith, it was as if someone came through his bedroom and took everything he owned.
His sleeping bag, medication and identification papers all were gone after cleanups of the homeless camps along Fountain Creek south of downtown Colorado Springs where Smith lived.
For Smith, there’s nothing abstract about the debate over whether the cleanups are a violation of constitutional rights or a legal and valid community effort to clear away litter.
It’s life and death, he said.
“We didn’t want to be this way,” Smith said of the plight of homeless people during a recent interview. “We got stuck this way, and we’re trying to work our way out, and there’s no way to do it because people keep on taking stuff from us. We have no rights. We get targeted.”
Smith’s story is similar to that of several other homeless people who camp along the creek. They said they routinely lose their belongings in surprise sweeps of their camps on public land. Some view the sweeps as a demonstration the city, and society at large, regard homeless people as second-class citizens.
“I’m underneath the same Constitution as everyone else in the United States,” Smith said.
“What makes them take my rights away by going through my stuff, taking my stuff? It’s a violation.”
The cleanups of homeless camps conducted by a nonprofit organization called Keep Colorado Springs Beautiful, under a contract with the city, have raised questions about what rights homeless people have, and who safeguards them.
People on all sides acknowledge homeless people have the same constitutional rights as everyone else. But the legal and ethical issues get sticky for a group of people whose day-to-day life involves breaking the law. Like many cities, Colorado Springs ordinances basically make it illegal to be homeless, banning activities such as camping or sleeping in some public places.
Cleaning homeless camps likely has no effect on whether people remain homeless, said Bob Holmes, director of Homeward Pikes Peak, an agency that coordinates services for homeless people. The sweeps are mostly a hassle for people who live in the camps, he said.
“This is a two-handed situation. On the one hand it’s illegal to camp, and it begins to pose a health hazard because these people aren’t real good at sanitation,” Holmes said.”On the other hand, where do they go? People can argue pretty vociferously on both sides.”
The issue went public in October when Robert Moran, who leads The Street Church for homeless people, took video of police officers and a cleanup crew for Keep Colorado Springs Beautiful picking through a homeless camp under a bridge near Dorchester Park.
The scenes that concerned some showed an officer opening a suitcase and looking through its contents, and cleanup workers stuffing blankets and sleeping bags into trash bags. City officials justified the officer’s actions by saying he was looking for illegal weapons or drugs, and Keep Colorado Springs Beautiful said it trashes only “abandoned property.”
Jon Schmidt, a homeless man who’s lived in Colorado Springs for a year and three months, said he often watches over his belongings and those of his campmates to guard against theft. He said he’s lost items in two cleanups, including blankets, a tent, a pocket knife, hair clippers and a mattress.
“There is constitutional rights. The police they do, in my personal opinion, try their best to defend our rights, but the Springs beautification program, I feel like they violate our rights mainly because they take our stuff. They pretty much steal from us,” Schmidt said.
Keep Colorado Springs Beautiful Executive Director Deborah Cunningham said the organization would never knowingly violate the rights of homeless people. On Oct. 23, she temporarily called off the cleanups of homeless camps after the Colorado Veterans Alliance threatened to sue on behalf of homeless people who are veterans.
At the same time, Colorado Springs officials said they would review the legal and ethical questions critics raised.
City spokeswoman Sue Skiffington-Blumberg said Wednesday that review hasn’t yet yielded any conclusions or new city policies. Keep Colorado Springs Beautiful organized the cleanups as part of a $45,000 contract with the city.
The director of the Colorado Veterans Alliance, former Marine Capt. Rick Duncan, said Wednesday the group is holding off on filing a lawsuit because the city appears to be cooperating.
Police also denied violating the rights of homeless people.
“We exist to serve all people, whether they’re employed or not, whether they own a home or not, whether they’re a veteran or not, whether they drive a car or not,” Police Chief Richard Myers said at a meeting with reporters.
Government agencies across the nation have wrestled with similar issues, said Tulin Ozdeger, an attorney and civil rights director for the National Center on Homelessness and Poverty, an advocacy group for homeless people.
“Everybody has equal access to public spaces, even if you’re homeless you still have the right to equal access to public spaces,” Ozdeger said. “Even in an instance where somebody is maybe violating an anti-camping law, they still have constitutional rights to their property, so that cannot be taken away and there should be some due process followed in that kind of situation.”
In July, the Center on Homelessness and Poverty put out a document citing four governments as having “model approaches to cleaning public spaces” – Washington, D.C.; Cincinnati; Portland and the state of Oregon.
The essential points of each policy involve cooperation with charities that serve the homeless, giving homeless people notice before a camp is cleaned and storing valuable property until a homeless person can retrieve it, Ozdeger said.
“When somebody doesn’t have any place to go or to store their belongings, they don’t necessarily give up their right to those belongings,” she said.
Those policies are basically in line with how the police department and Keep Colorado Springs Beautiful said they handle sweeps of camps. Homeless people and advocates for them said the reality is different.
Police Cmdr. Kurt Pillard said one responsibility of police who accompany cleanup crews is to recover valuable items such as ID documents and legal papers.
“Once they recover that type of information, the officers try to identify who owns those items and then places those items in the evidence custodian’s office so the rightful owner can claim them,” he said.
Pillard later told The Gazette there’s no accounting of how many items are recovered or returned to their owners. The evidence custodian’s office doesn’t track property according to a person’s homeless status, he said.
Pillard also said police officers give notice to homeless people that a camp will be cleaned, but in some cases it’s impossible to reach a camp’s occupants because they aren’t around. Homeless people disputed that, saying the camp sweeps are often immediate, and when notice comes they’re often allowed only a few minutes to gather their things.
The immediate problem for a homeless person is losing gear that helps them survive sleeping outside, said Moran, the leader of The Street Church. On a recent tour of several homeless camps, Moran pointed out both trash and apparent valuables that he said are often grabbed in sweeps.
“This is obviously not trash. It’s not wet, it’s not dirty,” he said of a purple sleeping bag under the bridge near Dorchester Park.
On the other side of some brush several yards away, a homeless man said he was there to watch over the camp.
Next to Fountain Creek, plastic containers and empty grocery bags were strewn around, and a mattress was laying in the water.
–
Contact the writer: 636-0187 or perry.swanson@gazette.com
Photo by





