Finger pushing


Community banks react to rapid industry changes

DES MOINES, Iowa • As Congress and the Bush administration spar over the proposed $700 billion bailout of troubled financial firms, small-town bankers are working to make sure they’re not forgotten.

Community bank groups responded quickly as policymakers devised solutions that could cost some banks millions of dollars or create unfair competition between hometown banks and Wall Street investment firms.

A central problem: About 800 banks nationwide have invested heavily in preferred stock in the mortgage companies Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, said Paul Merski, the chief economist at the Washington-based Independent Community Bankers of America.

The preferred stock was believed to be a safe investment for banks because it had the backing of the government, and it provided a reliable revenue stream through quarterly dividends.

Because of the way the government structured the bailout of Fannie and Freddie on Sept. 7, the preferred shares became nearly worthless, requiring the banks to write off their investment as a loss, Merski said. Regulations prohibit banks from writing off investment losses against regular income, which creates what Merski calls a double whammy – a real capital loss and no way to recoup even a portion by a tax write-off as a loss.

They should at least be allowed to do that, said John Sorensen, president and CEO of the Iowa Bankers Association.

“Part of the reason it’s important to do that is that any impact this financial crisis and resulting federal legislation has on community banks, is only going to reduce the amount of lending that takes places on Main Street,” said Sorensen. “They’re the ones that are rolling up sleeves actively trying to make local economies better.”

Of the $36 billion wrapped up in Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac preferred stock, about $16 billion is held by banks, Merski said. The invested losses range from $100,000 at some banks to $100 million at a few others.

One bank, for example, Lynchburg, Va.-based Bank of the James said Sept. 18 that it expects to write down more than $1.5 million in losses due to the government’s treatment of Fannie Mae stock.

The investment is about 4 percent of the bank’s investment portfolio and about 1 percent of its assets, said Todd Scruggs, the bank’s vice president.

He noted that the bank’s shares in Fannie Mae preferred stock paid dividends of about $40,000 per quarter.

Another bank with more at stake is Gateway Financial Holdings Inc., which is expecting to write off about $38 million, nearly a quarter of its $164 million capital.

On Wednesday, the Virginia Beach, Va.-based bank announced it will be acquired by Hampton Roads Bankshares Inc. in a $101 million deal.

Company officials did not immediately return calls seeking comment.

While the bailout of Fannie and Freddie continued to play out, the government acted quickly to fix a separate issue with an action that could harm local banks.

In an effort to stem the financial crisis, the government said it would provide a government guarantee for money-market mutual funds.

The ICBA and the American Bankers Association said providing the insurance created an immediate and unfair competition for certificates of deposit and money-market deposit accounts offered by community banks.Suku Radia, president of Des Moines-based Bankers Trust Co., said that bankers understand that stability is needed in the financial system but that the government bailout of large investment banks to the detriment of local banks makes no sense.

“I’m always a very big believer in competing on an even playing field, but I don’t like it when the playing field is tilted against me,” he said. “This country was built on capitalism and the free-market system and all of a sudden the government is saying as of right now, the free-market system is going to go against you because we’re going to define what the free market is.”

An attractive aspect of the community banks’ money-market deposit accounts is that they have always been insured by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp.

The government guarantee provided for money-market mutual funds – which invest in short-term securities such as Treasury bills – would give customers incentive to withdraw money from bank CDs and accounts to put into the money-market mutual funds, where they could potentially earn higher interest.

 

Photo by

Tags news


Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests