Finger pushing


What are your kids missing?

If last year is any indication, students in 30 Colorado Springs School District 11 classrooms will show up for their first day of school on Aug. 18 and be greeted by a substitute teacher.Those 30 teachers are a small percentage of the more than 2,050 teachers in the area’s largest district, and they may have been sick, or in a hospital, or tending to a family emergency. The reasons really don’t matter, because D-11 teachers get 11 days of paid leave per school year, to take when they want.It’s almost a guarantee there will be additional teacher absences throughout the year, not only in D-11, but in the other 16 districts in the Pikes Peak region that give teachers an array of leave time for illness, family emergencies and personal reasons.But when teachers aren’t in their classrooms, many local and national officials say, student schedules are interrupted and learning may suffer. In a world where test scores are publicized and scrutinized, one national study found that the more teachers are absent before testing, the poorer their students perform on the tests.One area district began ad- dressing the issue last year by offering a monetary bonus for employees who had fewer than seven absences, defined as missing more than three hours in a day. Harrison School District 2 Superintendent Mike Miles said the district’s absentee rate wasn’t bad, but there was interest in making it better.In the first year of the program, the full attendance rate – meaning the percentage of employees attending work the entire day – improved from 93.9 to 94.6 between the 2006-07 and the 2007-08 school year.In all, about 1,650 of Harrison’s teachers and support employees earned a check for 1 percent of their salary this summer by having fewer than seven absences. The total payout for the district was about $230,000.Absentee statistics vary by district, but the sentiment is the same everywhere:”You want your teachers there. They provide the best instruction,” said Sarah Nobles, executive director for Human Resources in Widefield School District 3.At the same time, teachers need flexibility in their schedule to deal with illness or a family emergency or event, said Tami Hasling, D-11 parent and school board president. Bosses in other industries don’t typically limit when employees can take a vacation, she said, and it would be tough to tell teachers they can’t attend a family wedding or other event because it doesn’t fall during their breaks.

When a teacher is absentAny discussion of teacher absences inevitably leads to the other side of the story: substitute teachers.Years ago, teachers might leave lesson plans that were more fun and for enrichment, said Maggie Lopez, assistant superintendent for learning services at Academy School District 20. But their role has become more complex because of the focus on testing and instruction.”It’s teaching,” Lopez said. “It’s not just being there as a person for kids. You’re not baby-sitting.”As such, Lopez said, “teachers try really hard to leave meaningful plans for substitutes.” And many districts, including D-20, provide training for subs.But substitutes are not bound by the same professional requirements as teachers. Some have a teaching license; others have a bachelor’s degree in another subject or a high school diploma, coupled with experience working with students. All substitutes must apply and receive authorization from the Colorado Department of Education.And having a substitute in the classroom can be difficult, Hasling said, leading to a disruptive classroom that affects learning.”It affects the classroom in the manner of discipline, consistency,” she said.Many substitutes choose to teach grade levels and subjects they are comfortable with, said D-11 Deputy Superintendent Mary Thurman, and someone at the school typically checks in and can help if a substitute is having trouble.Over time, some subs figure out ways to keep students on task and learning. Sherrie Klayton, a substitute teacher in D-20, offers rewards, such as free time figuring out a frog puzzle she always carries or a polished rock to give to a student she sees going “above and beyond” in some way.But having a good lesson plan is the first step to ensuring a sub’s success, Thurman said.Even with the best lesson plans, however, there can be some scrambling to find a teacher’s calendar, the bag for lunch money and other things, said Kathy Beers, a substitute teacher in the Widefield district.”It’s like going into someone else’s kitchen,” she said.Sometimes having a substitute means students watch a movie about a subject, instead of doing an activity or getting a lecture from the teacher, said parent Mike Bergst.But, Bergst said that in his seven years as Palmer High School’s BAAC president, he never had a complaint about teacher absences.

CostsBecause teacher absences are inevitable, districts must budget for substitutes. The district ends up paying both the teacher’s salary and the cost of the substitute, which ranges from $85 to $105 per day in the Pikes Peak region.Widefield pays $5 extra to substitutes working Fridays because it’s hard to find substitutes those days, Nobles said.”There aren’t enough subs sometimes,” District 2’s Miles said.If classes are small, they can be combined or split among other teachers. Occasionally an administrator will take the employee’s duty.”It really is not ideal for educating students,” Miles said.Several national studies have looked at the relationship between teacher absences and student achievement; one likened the effect of 10 days of a teacher’s absence to the difference between a student having a brand-new teacher as opposed to a more experienced second-year teacher. In math specifically, 10 teacher absences can cause a significant loss in achievement, the study found.Even those studies, however, caution district officials from reducing the sick and personal days teachers can take because it will add stress to teachers’ jobs and encourage them to come to work sick.Changing the culture of a school might be a better solution. Researchers found that in some schools, teachers do everything to avoid taking absences unless they were sick or had a valid reason. In other schools, being absent was seen as an entitlement.Most teachers want to be in their classroom, Nobles said, and know how important it is for them to be there in a time when academics and test scores are judged.”They know they provide the best instruction,” she said. “They feel guilty if they’re gone.”And if guilt isn’t a motivator, maybe the type of bonus program that D-2 offers can be. The district will keep data for several years to see if the incentive program continues to make a difference in absences, Miles said.-Contact the Writer: 636-0394 or shari.griffin@gazette.com

 

Photo by

Tags main story


Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests