City Council’s math doesn’t add up
The City Council opposes tax relief. Surprise, surprise. What is shocking, even scary, is their incompetence with basic numbers. They can’t add. No wonder they always claim a fiscal crisis, year after year. They hysterically attacked both reform petitions, for which we filed 50 percent more signatures than required. They proved yet again they will say and do anything to deceive citizens into voting against any modest proposal for fiscal discipline. EXAMPLE 1: Apart from the overtly illegal stormwater tax ended by these petitions, the city collects a secret tax of $27 million on our utility bills. Our petition phases out that hidden tax in 10 equal yearly steps. That saves us $2.7 million in 2009, $5.4 million in 2010, $8.1 million in 2011, etc. All savings go to utility customer accounts in equal dollar amounts. Compare that gradual approach to current scheming for a $72 million instant tax increase. The city said the “cut” is $35 million, because they added $8 million that cityowned enterprises now pay the city for lawyers, accountants, and other overhead. Wrong! As payments phase out, city services to enterprises will also. The net loss to the city is not $8 million, but zero. An $8 million “mistake.” EXAMPLE 2: Even if we accept their crazy, inflated $35 million figure, the city said the first of 10 equal cuts would be $3.5 million, but the 10th year loss is $40.5 million. Wrong again. The petition requires all 10 steps be equal, and 10 x 3.5 equals 35, not 40.5. Their $5.5 million “mistake” in multiplication gets them an “F” in third-grade math. CSAP tests, anyone? EXAMPLE 3: When you add their (false) cumulative figures of $3.5 million in 2009, $7 million in 2010, $10.5 million in 2011, etc., the 10-year total is $192.5 million. The city claimed $212 million, another $19.5 million “mistake.” Remember, the real numbers are an added $2.7 million yearly for a total utility customer savings of $148.5 million spread over 10 years. The council’s bogus $212 million figure is another $63.5 million “mistake.” That $148.5 million still sounds like a lot of money, but put it in perspective. City budgets historically grow over 5 percent. This year’s is $360 million, up $12 million from 2007. Apply only this year’s 3.44 percent increase, compounded over the next 10 years. The 10th year budget would be $505 million, not this year’s $360 million. Over 10 years, the $148.5 million total savings is only 3.4 percent of total city revenue of $4.36 billion. Yet they dare say this 3.4 percent tax cut phased in over 10 years is “crushing!” Remember, their revenue still grows every year. We are only slowing the rate of increase temporarily. Also, their budget includes only part of city revenue, not tens of millions in yearly RTA taxes spent on city roads, nor their other tricks, like misuse of hospital and utility “enterprise” resources. They also claim spending $15 million yearly in stormwater taxes will solve the alleged $300 million-plus “backlog” (wish list) of drainage projects the council intentionally neglected for decades to justify this tax increase. Wrong again. If yearly construction costs rise only 5 percent, the city will make no progress. If they rise 6 percent, we fall behind. That doesn’t count wasteful city enterprise overhead that does not fix one drainage channel. The only sensible solutions are to make drainage spending a true priority within the ever-growing city budget, and to sell off surplus city property. Putting back on the tax rolls assets like parking lots, shopping centers, golf courses, ice rinks, hospitals, tennis courts, utilities, etc. would pay for all needed drainage work, with many hundreds of millions left over. Their most absurd claim is that we must pay the stormwater tax to control water runoffi fffecting Pueblo. Why? So Pueblo will feel better about our taking water from the reservoir to pipe up here. Utility rates now pay for new water lines, and higher water rates are coming. Why? Subsidizing new subdivisions adds to profits of the land speculators and developers who own the City Council (and oppose me). Is that how you want your taxes wasted? Disgusted by the council’s bogus figures? By their ordering the city manager to invent gloom-and-doom “scenarios” to scare voters? By their threats of floods, death, and seizure of your home, just to keep their stupid rain tax? Then visit www.CityReforms.com to learn more, and volunteer to help pass the two city tax relief petitions. You owe it to your family, your finances, and your future. Bruce is the state representative from House District 15 and the author of the two reform petitions. Contact him at taxcutter@msn.com.
Hanover School District 28 superintendent Henry Roman walked the halls of Hanover Junior High and High School. Roman is retiring after four years working to improve the district’s academic standing and overall health. Photo by (KIRK SPEER, THE GAZETTE)





