The 1895 Victor train robbery

By Steve Plutt, Special to the Courier

In celebration of Colorado’s 150th birthday and the United States’ 250th, local historian Steve Plutt and the Ute Pass Historical Society have written a series of stories to bring the area’s colorful history to life.


In the American West, boom towns drew a wide range of characters, from the respectable to the despicable, and the gold mining district of Teller County was no anomaly in this regard.

Although the respectable constituted the majority, we certainly encountered our share of the appalling. Historical accounts confirm that even the infamous American con artist and gangster Soapy Smith, who operated confidence schemes across the Western United States, was active in our area.

Local outlaws like Robert Smith were also part of our community, with Smith being notorious for his role in the $16,000 1895 Grassy Express Stage robbery. Or the three Victor youths who robbed the Kuykendall Stage in 1896.

The Florence and Cripple Creek Railroad is remembered for being a groundbreaking short-line railroad that played a key role in opening up the Cripple Creek-Victor mining district to the outside world. When the F.&C.C.R.R. arrived in the District in May 1894, it didn’t take long for the company to become a prime target for bandits, and its history was punctuated by the dramatic train robbery of 1895.

It was on March 23, 1895, that the first train robbery took place in our vicinity. Leaving the train station at 9:40 p.m., Engine No. 6, belonging to the Florence and Cripple Creek Railroad, steamed out of the Victor Depot en route to Florence.

Just 10 minutes and only about a mile into its journey, a scheme created by local gangster Bob Taylor was effectively set in motion.

Taylor and his band of masked outlaws, consisting of five other men, stood ready as the No. 6 drew near. Two of those men stood beside the tracks waving a railroad signal lamp, which made the locomotive slow way down. As it was rolling to a stop, one bandit, Kid Wallace, jumped on and crawled over the top of the tender to the engine. He pointed his revolver down at the engineer and ordered him to stop the train. The engineer complied and the rest of the gang then boarded. The Kid stayed atop the tender, keeping guard of the engineer and fireman while his partner kept watch of the outside of the passenger train.

Kid Wal;lace. (Courtesy Steve Plutt)

Taylor and Ora Wilder, Bill Gibson and Sherman Crumbley broke into the Express car and held the express messenger at gunpoint. Nothing of value to them was found, so they left the Express car and made the messenger take the lead and carry an empty mailsack into the passenger cars. At gunpoint, the passengers had to empty all of their valuables into the sack.

As the bandits were leaving the train, they actually handed the messenger a 25-cent tip for holding the bag for them while they robbed everyone! After that, the gang left the train, disappearing into the darkness with a sack full of money and “(gold) watches, rings and diamond pins galore,” the Rocky Mountain News reported.

No one was injured and the train was delayed 35 minutes when the engineer left and steamed down the tracks to the first station where he telegraphed back to the Victor Depot, the happenings. The following morning at 10 o’clock, a special train arrived from Walsenburg with a seasoned bloodhound. The hound tracked the scent directly to the “hideaway” shack situated on the Strong Mine property.

Arrested were Bob Taylor, a former deputy sheriff, Bill Gibson, another ex-deputy, Frank “The Kid” Wallace, Ora Wilder, along with Sherman Crumley, and Louis Vaneck. All of them except Taylor were employed at the Strong Mine. Taylor and Gibson were held on a $10,000 bond while the other three were released, but re-arrested a month later when officials had obtained more evidence against them.

At the trial, Louis Vaneck decided to cooperate with the government and took the stand against his former partners in crime. According to newspaper accounts, his motive was that he felt cheated by Taylor when the loot was sold up in Denver and divvied up. He also testified that Taylor was the individual responsible for orchestrating the entire scheme.

Vaneck’s time on the stand likewise suggested that Bill Gibson was asleep in the Strong Mine cabin at the time of the robbery, ultimately resulting in Gibson’s acquittal owing to a lack of adequate evidence being provided.

On July 25, 1895, following the conclusion of the prosecution’s case and an extensive 20-hour deliberation, Judge Hallett inquired of the foreman whether they had reached a consensus. The response was negative, with seven individuals voting in favor of acquittal and five in favor of conviction. A hung jury was declared by the judge, and a new trial will be scheduled. Taylor and Wallace’s bail was set at $10,000 each , and Crumbley and Wilder’s at $500; however, none of the men could afford that amount and were consequently left sitting in jail.

At the re-trial that fall, Crumbley was released due to lack of evidence and Lewis Vaneck was released on an order from a U.S. Marshall. But the other three were found guilty. Bob Taylor and Ora Wilder were each sentenced to 10 years in the Cañon City penitentiary while Kid Wallace received an 8-year sentence in the same institution.


PREV

PREVIOUS

Aging infrastructure, high costs contribute to water failures in rural Colorado

Colorado is in a drought, and the snowpack is the lowest it’s ever been recorded. But for some communities, the most intrusive water worry might have less to do with the larger environmental forces at play and more to do with pipes. “Once it’s buried, it’s forgotten,” said Victor City Administrator Bobby Tech. The former […]

NEXT

NEXT UP

Codie continues Vahsholtz legacy in twin-turbo Ford

Codie Vahsholtz has never been afraid to embrace change. The longtime racer out of Woodland Park zoomed up America’s Mountain on Sunday in the 104th Broadmoor Pikes Peak International Hill Climb in his usual 2013 Ford Open Vahsholtz custom. The results of the race were not available until after this edition of the Pikes Peak […]


Welcome Back.

Streak: 9 days i

Stories you've missed since your last login:

Stories you've saved for later:

Recommended stories based on your interests:

Edit my interests